Why The “Trump Rally” Is A Fraud

by Pebblewriter, Pebblewriter.com

— reposted from pebblewriter.com, originally published 01 March 2017

I very seriously doubt that Trump, nor anyone for that matter, can sharply expand spending while slashing taxes without generating higher inflation and, thereby, higher interest rates.

Yet the “market” continues to melt up, supposedly because the new administration will be so beneficial to the economy. What gives?

Without question, trend followers have jumped on board after seeing stocks make new highs. But, it should be obvious by now that prices are way ahead of any improvements in fundamentals – both current and promised.

The past two days are a great example of what’s really driving stock higher the past several months: well-timed spurts in USDJPY and CL and downdrafts in VIX. Our latest Big Picture post [see: Big Picture Feb 22, 2017] shows how these forces have been in play for years.

A rising USDJPY is, of course, the primary sign that the yen carry trade is at work. And, VIX, formerly an indicator of risk, is now regularly used to goose algorithms which spur stock buying every time VIX ticks lower and/or breaks below support. CL is a general, all-purpose price booster with a very outsized impact.

THE PAST SEVERAL MONTHS

Since the election, SPX has traced out a rising channel, shown below in purple. In late January, it took on a steeper trajectory, shown as the red channel below. This red channel sliced through a Fib level that might ordinarily serve as overhead resistance — the white 1.618 at 2335.34 — without so much as a backtest.

So, it made sense that, after a reasonable amount of time and a couple percent, SPX would return to backtest it. Beginning on Feb 21, SPX started to trace out a falling channel, also shown in red. It was well-formed, meaning it offered several lows and a couple of highs that lay along parallel lines. And, it aimed for the 1.618 around March 6.

THE PAST TWO DAYS

There’s nothing very unusual about the past two days. We’ve seen the very same factors play out that drive prices higher on a day-to-day, even moment-to-moment, basis. It’s instructive, though, to see what’s working lately.

When SPX opened the morning of Feb 24, it gapped lower to tag the bottom of the falling red channel where it intersected with the bottom of the rising red channel (the first yellow arrow.) It was an obvious spot for a bounce — which we noted at the time.

VIX, which had made a special point of climbing from its close at 11.7 the day before to 12.59 just before the open (a 7.6% spike), dropped like a rock moments later, gapping back down to 11.66 by 10am.

VIX’s plunge ensured a sharp bounce. But, what then? How to keep the rally going? First, VIX quickly reset back to 12.49 where it began a slow, steady decline that only algos could love. It helped SPX slowly churn its way back to the top of the channel.

In the final 30 minutes, as SPX approached the top of the falling red channel and VIX had reached the bottom of its rising yellow channel, VIX plunged through channel support (the white arrow) and dropped to a new low at 11.34 — a 9.9% plunge from its overnight highs. The algos went nuts, and SPX closed above the falling red channel top — a breakout.

It didn’t matter that VIX jumped right back in the rising yellow channel the next morning. SPX had broken out, and all that stood between it and new all-time highs was a backtest.

VIX pulled the same stunt the next day, ramping in the pre-market hours Monday morning so it could plunge when the “market” opened and drive prices even higher. Fortunately, CL broke out overnight (the yellow arrow), keeping futures prices on the rise.

But, Monday morning was problematic. Durable goods and pending home sales both missed. Futures were off 9 points from their overnight highs. There was real buying pressure in VIX, and it started ticking higher after its initial plunge. Traders didn’t believe stocks’ new highs.

By noon, SPX was struggling and CL had reached resistance. VIX was still climbing. The only tool left was USDJPY. It had been following a falling red channel since the previous Wednesday, but suddenly (the red arrow) felt the need to spike higher and break out of the channel (the white arrow), a rally that continued until stocks closed for the day.

While USDJPY broke out of the falling red channel, there were other, bigger channels that spelled more downside. And, it hadn’t quite tagged its SMA100 — an obvious attraction slightly lower. But, USDJPY’s spike was just powerful enough to offset VIX’s continuing rise and, more importantly, enough to push SPX to a slight gain and new, all-time highs.

After the close, USDJPY reset back to the SMA100, CL’s rising purple channel broke down, and VIX continued to gain momentum. To make matters worse, GDP and trade deficit numbers disappointed the following morning. S&P futures were off 7 points as stocks prepared to open.

SPX gapped down 5 points before VIX started dipping. But, it wasn’t enough. By 11:25, CL had shed 2.6% from its highs the previous day, and RBOB was off 4.8%. Stocks, used to being supported by CL, were feeling very let down.

At 12:26, SPX completed a backtest of the falling red channel at 2358.96 — potential support. Does it surprise anyone that VIX reached the top of the rising yellow channel (the yellow arrow) and reversed at exactly that same moment? Or, that CL chose that exact same moment to bounce at a slightly higher low (also, a yellow arrow) of 53.19? Or, that USDJPY started spiking higher at exactly that same moment?

SPX had completed a small Head & Shoulders Pattern that targeted 2356.87. But, given the sharp rallies in both CL and USDJPY, it spent the rest of the day trying to rise above the neckline (red, dashed line.) It appeared the 2356 tag, if it was going to happen, would have to wait until the next morning – this morning.

It looked possible, given that the red channel had broken down earlier that day. The only hitch was Trump’s speech later that night. Could he suspend the laws of mathematics and present a cogent plan to sharply increase spending while lowering taxes and staving off inflation and higher interest rates?

In the end, it didn’t matter. Aside from not further alienating half the country, Trump’s speech was long on rhetoric and short on details. It didn’t accomplish much.

USDJPY, on the other hand, was very busy. It extended its rally — now up 2.1% since yesterday morning. CL did the same — gaining 2.4% until this morning’s EIA inventory report reminded everyone that oil prices should be much lower.

VIX, which had reached 12.96 just before yesterday’s close, started dropping immediately afterwards, reaching 11.86 (a 8.4% plunge) as of this morning’s 8:30 data dump. It dropped again after this morning’s EIA report gave CL permission to decline (only to support at the SMA10, of course), bouncing at the bottom of the yellow channel for the 7th time in the past week.

The result: SPX and ES are currently up about 30 points.

LOOKING FORWARD

Does it matter why SPX keeps hitting new highs, or should we ignore the details and keep on buying the dips? Surely, there are limits to the manipulation or what it can accomplish?

It’s hard to say. Since election night last November, USDJPY rallied 17%, crude rallied 30%, and VIX collapsed 56%. There’s your Trump rally.

The challenge in forecasting stocks each day is that these drivers take turns. If oil suddenly starts dumping, it’s a safe bet that USDJPY will suddenly start spiking or VIX start plunging. It’s like a hydra, with a new factor sprouting whenever another is cut off.

I’ve mentioned to many clients that it’s become easier to trade USDJPY, CL and VIX themselves rather than equities. As tools, their individual actions are much easier to forecast than their combined effects.

Having said that, here’s where things shake out.

Oil prices are problematic. We’ve touched on this many times, noting that CPI broke out of a long-term trend with its Jan print — which should be even higher in Feb (due out Mar 15, the morning of the FOMC’s next rate decision and Yellen press conference.)

We’ve also discussed, however, that gasoline prices have dropped further and faster than oil. If the last CPI print at 2.5% was acceptable, then a modest CL drop could hold the Feb CPI number to 2.7 or 2.8% and give the Fed cover to raise rates a bit. Who knows, the PCE might even approach 2% (though, I doubt it.)

Once the Feb 2016 lows are digested, YoY comparisons won’t be so alarming. All the Fed will have to worry about (or not) is John Q’s ability to pay his bills with his declining real income.

USDJPY is an interesting case. It’s a currency pair, meaning the dollar will have to increase from its already overvalued levels in order to, along with a falling yen, goose the yen carry trade.

It has proven hugely effective in years past, driving the bulk of the 2011-2015 gains in stocks. But, as the BoJ discovered in 2014, a very cheap yen creates very real inflation — especially if fuel prices remain at elevated levels. Four percent inflation is an inconvenient truth when trying to justify the most accommodative monetary policy of all time in an effort to reach 2%.

IMO, this reality was the impetus for oil’s crash — which, not so coincidentally, began on the same day that the USDJPY broke out. A little mutually beneficial back-scratching, perhaps?

And, you can bet the Fed and politicians alike are keeping a close eye on the trade deficit — which will continue to grow with the USD’s every tick higher.

VIX is the current reigning champion of market manipulation. It knows no bounds (other than zero) and has no obligations to reality — economic or otherwise. It’s a rare day when VIX doesn’t suddenly start dropping — goosing stocks in process — on no news whatsoever, other than that stocks are slipping below an acceptable level or need a nudge to get past resistance.

TPTB discovered the extent of VIX’s power following the Brexit sell-off. So, after years of respecting a long-term channel (in yellow below) VIX has been hammered below it countless times since election night’s “miraculous” recovery in equity futures (VIX plunged even while equities were plummeting.)

As a chartist, it’s difficult to know when these moments will arise. Often, for instance, VIX will construct a series of intraday lows — simply to have a trend line below which to plunge later in the day! And, as occurred last night, there is rarely any correlation between its close one day and open the following morning — meaning frequent head fakes and sleepless nights for those who don’t go to cash every night.

CONCLUSIONS

Like most of our readers, I went to a great business school, studied under brilliant and highly-respected professors, read all the top books, magazines and newspapers (kinda like the internet, but on paper.) I worked with some of the brightest analysts for some of the top firms on Wall Street. I also have undergraduate degrees in math and economics, and still put in 60-80 hour weeks reading, studying, learning.

And, I can tell you, I have never seen the “markets” as heavily manipulated as they currently are. It was one thing when QE came along and there was a rising tide lifting all boats. But, this is different. It has become much more closely managed — to the point where hardly anything happens that isn’t either preplanned or carefully controlled.

I spoke to a group of financial engineering grad students from my alma mater the other day — very bright young men and women. One of the things they teach these days is using big data to discover and define the factors that drive the prices of investment assets — everything from financial reports to web traffic, patent filings and satellite imagery.

I even took it upon myself to learn Python so I could play around with some ideas that pop into my head from time to time. Quantitative analysis has become increasingly prominent, as evidenced by the growing number of quantitatively-driven hedge funds in the top 10.

Two observations stand out. First, most analysts, trained in random walk theory, efficient frontiers and various fundamentally-driven pricing models, remain completely unaware of the degree to which algorithms impact prices on a daily basis and, even, moment to moment.

The other observation is the scary one. There are only so many relevant data points in the universe. If we’re all observing the same data, then a majority of us will come to similar conclusions regarding pricing and, thus, seek to buy and sell at similar times. In other words, those following the important indicators constitute a crowd which could have great difficulty squeezing through the doors when (not “if”) the theater catches fire.

We saw this play out on Black Monday in 1987. We saw it again in 1998 when LTCM melted down. We saw it after the internet bubble popped in 2000-2003, and again in 2007-2009 when mortgages blew up.

More recently, we saw it happen in 2011, when our analog played out (despite very heavy central bank influence.) It almost occurred with Brexit and the US elections, but was successfully beaten back. What about the next time?

We can’t know exactly when or what the next catalyst will be. But, it’s safe to say there will be one. With CAPE (the chart above) edging back above all but its 2000 highs, it could be a doozy. In fact, if everyone is crowded into the same trade, betting on the same outcome, it increases the odds of the next time being truly devastating.

READ MORE: