Written by Steve Keen, Steve Keen’s Debtwatch
Minsky’s Financial Instability Hypothesis (FIH) is an emergent property of macroeconomic models derived directly from macroeconomic definitions.
This is Part 5 of a paper presented at the International Conference Minsky at 100 Revisiting Financial Instability, December 16-17 2019 – Universita Cattolica del Sacro Cuore Milano.
![growth.rates.caption](https://econintersect.com/images/2019/12/15242034growth.rates.caption.PNG)
Please share this article – Go to very top of page, right hand side, for social media buttons.
This paper is posted in five parts:
Part 1: Deriving a Minsky Model
Part 2: Simulating Loanable Funds and BOMD
Part 3: Accounting For The Great Moderation & The Great Recession
Part 4: Nonlinearity and Realism
Part 5: Appendix and References (this article)
Appendix
The basic linear Minsky model is:
![keen.2019.dec.15.equations.1](https://econintersect.com/images/2019/12/3302739keen.2019.dec.15.equations.1.21.PNG)
Where the following shorthand expressions are used:
![keen.2019.dec.15.equations.1.22](https://econintersect.com/images/2019/12/33308141keen.2019.dec.15.equations.1.22.PNG)
Spelling out these shorthand expressions yields the fully specified model, which makes it easier to identify the nonlinear feedbacks in this model. Variables that interact nonlinearly with other variables in this system are highlighted in red: there are two dampening nonlinear feedbacks in the equation for λ, one amplifying feedback for ω, and two amplifying feedbacks for d (including one term in d-squared):
![keen.2019.dec.15.equations.1.23](https://econintersect.com/images/2019/12/62622577keen.2019.dec.15.equations.1.23.PNG)
The “good” equilibrium of this model can be derived by solving for the zeros of these equations via the substitution that
![keen.2019.dec.15.pi](https://econintersect.com/images/2019/12/41102669keen.2019.dec.15.pi.PNG)
yields:
![keen.2019.dec.15.equations.1.24](https://econintersect.com/images/2019/12/9596781keen.2019.dec.15.equations.1.24.PNG)
This equilibrium is in terms of the profit share, employment rate and debt ratio: the wages share is a derivative of these, since
![keen.2019.dec.15.omega](https://econintersect.com/images/2019/12/81720245keen.2019.dec.15.omega.PNG)
This residual role for the wages-share of output manifests itself in the model dynamics as well: before the crisis, the wages share falls as the debt level rises, while the profit share fluctuates around its equilibrium. This confirms Marx’s intuition in Capital I that wages are a dependent variable in capitalism:
“To put it mathematically: the rate of accumulation is the independent, not the dependent, variable; the rate of wages, the dependent, not the independent, variable” ( – – Marx 1867, Chapter 25, Section 1)
Loanable Funds & BOMD
The key differential equations for the models of Loanable Funds and BOMD as shown in Equations (1.6) and (1.8) respectively. The definitions they share are shown in Equation (1.25):
![keen.2019.dec.15.equations.1.25](https://econintersect.com/images/2019/12/36556239keen.2019.dec.15.equations.1.25.PNG)
Deriving a Price Equation
This section derives a pricing equation similar to Kalecki’s markup pricing equation ( – – Kalecki 1938; – – Kalecki 1971; – – Kriesler 1988) from a simple monetary model of circulation. Price P is treated as an equilibrating function driven by the difference between the monetary value of demand D$ and the monetary value of output S$, where the rate of convergence is given by the time constant τp . Then we have
![keen.2019.dec.15.equation.1.26](https://econintersect.com/images/2019/12/5168968keen.2019.dec.15.equation.1.26.PNG)
The monetary value of output S$ is price P times physical output Q. Physical output divided by the output to labour ratio a determines employment L, so that we can write
![keen.2019.dec.15.Q.physical.output](https://econintersect.com/images/2019/12/6965075keen.2019.dec.15.Q.physical.output.PNG)
In this monetary model, employment is determined by the wage bill W divided by the money wage w$. The division of income between workers and capitalists is given by 0 > s > 1, with s x D$ going to capitalists as gross profits, while (1 – s) x D$ goes to workers as wages. Thus given:
![keen.2019.dec.15.equations.1.27](https://econintersect.com/images/2019/12/15670018keen.2019.dec.15.equations.1.27.PNG)
We can write S$ as:
![keen.2019.dec.15.equation.1.28](https://econintersect.com/images/2019/12/37055398keen.2019.dec.15.equation.1.28.PNG)
At the equilibrium price PE, the monetary value of supply equals that of demand, so that:
![keen.2019.dec.15.equation.1.29](https://econintersect.com/images/2019/12/96288270keen.2019.dec.15.equation.1.29.PNG)
Solving for PE yields:
![keen.2019.dec.15.equation.1.30](https://econintersect.com/images/2019/12/33905891keen.2019.dec.15.equation.1.30.PNG)
This can be rewritten in terms of the wages share of income ω:
![keen.2019.dec.15.equation.1.31](https://econintersect.com/images/2019/12/29841373keen.2019.dec.15.equation.1.31.PNG)
Therefore:
![keen.2019.dec.15.equation.1.32](https://econintersect.com/images/2019/12/40713697keen.2019.dec.15.equation.1.32.PNG)
This is equivalent to Kalecki’s markup pricing equation, with the markup being 1 divided by the workers share of income. We can now rewrite the inflation equation (1.26) in terms of the wages share of income:
![keen.2019.dec.15.equations.1.33](https://econintersect.com/images/2019/12/2549288keen.2019.dec.15.equations.1.33.PNG)
Monetary model
.
References
Anderson, P. W. (1972). “More Is Different.” Science 177(4047): 393-396.
Bernanke, B. S. (2000). Essays on the Great Depression. Princeton, Princeton University Press.
Biggs, M., T. Mayer, et al. (2010). “Credit and Economic Recovery: Demystifying Phoenix Miracles.” SSRN eLibrary.
Blatt, J. M. (1983). Dynamic economic systems: a post-Keynesian approach. Armonk, N.Y, M.E. Sharpe.
Borio, C. (2012) “The financial cycle and macroeconomics: What have we learnt?” BIS Working Papers.
Census, B. o. (1949). Historical Statistics of the United States 1789-1945. B. o. t. Census. Washington, United States Government.
Census, B. o. (1975). Historical Statistics of the United States Colonial Times to 1970. B. o. t. Census. Washington, United States Government.
Charles, S. (2005). “A Note on Some Minskyan Models of Financial Instability.” Studi Economici 60(86): 43-51.
Charles, S. (2008). “Teaching Minsky’s Financial Instability Hypothesis: A Manageable Suggestion.” Journal of Post Keynesian Economics 31(1): 125-138.
Constantinescu, M. and P. Lastauskas (2018). “The knotty interplay between credit and housing.” Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance: .
Cruz, M. (2005). “A Three-Regime Business Cycle Model for an Emerging Economy.” Applied Economics Letters 12(7): 399-402.
Dembiermont, C., M. Drehmann, et al. (2013). “How much does the private sector really borrow? A new database for total credit to the private nonfinancial sector.” BIS Quarterly Review(March): 65-81.
Deutsche Bundesbank (2017). “The role of banks, non- banks and the central bank in the money creation process.” Deutsche Bundesbank Monthly Report: 13-33.
Dow, S. C. (1997). Endogenous Money. A “second edition” of The general theory. G. C. Harcourt and P. A. Riach. London, Routledge. 2: 61-78.
Eggertsson, G. B. and P. Krugman (2012). “Debt, Deleveraging, and the Liquidity Trap: A Fisher-Minsky-Koo approach.” Quarterly Journal of Economics 127: 1469 – 1513.
Fama, E. F. and K. R. French (1999). Dividends, Debt, Investment, and Earnings. Working Papers, University of Chicago.
Fama, E. F. and K. R. French (2002). “Testing Trade-Off and Pecking Order Predictions about Dividends and Debt.” Review of Financial Studies 15(1): 1-33.
Fazzari, S., P. Ferri, et al. (2008). “Cash Flow, Investment, and Keynes-Minsky Cycles.” Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 65(3-4): 555-572.
Fisher, I. (1933). “The Debt-Deflation Theory of Great Depressions.” Econometrica 1(4): 337-357.
Friedman, M. (1969). The Optimum Quantity of Money. The Optimum Quantity of Money and Other Essays. Chicago, MacMillan: 1-50.
Fullwiler, S. T. (2013). “An endogenous money perspective on the post-crisis monetary policy debate.” Review of Keynesian Economics.
Goodwin, R. M. (1967). A growth cycle. Socialism, Capitalism and Economic Growth. C. H. Feinstein. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press: 54-58.
Gorman, W. M. (1953). “Community Preference Fields.” Econometrica 21(1): 63-80.
Grasselli, M. and B. Costa Lima (2012). “An analysis of the Keen model for credit expansion, asset price bubbles and financial fragility.” Mathematics and Financial Economics 6: 191-210.
Hills, S., R. Thomas, et al. (2010). “The UK recession in context – what do three centuries of data tell us?” Bank of England Quarterly Bulletin 2010 Q4: 277-291.
Holmes, A. R. (1969). Operational Constraints on the Stabilization of Money Supply Growth. Controlling Monetary Aggregates. F. E. Morris. Nantucket Island, The Federal Reserve Bank of Boston: 65-77.
Jarsulic, M. (1989). “Endogenous credit and endogenous business cycles.” Journal of Post Keynesian Economics 12: 35-48.
Jorda, O., M. Schularick, et al. (2011). “Financial Crises, Credit Booms, and External Imbalances: 140 Years of Lessons.” IMF Economic Review 59(2): 340-378.
Kalecki, M. (1938). “The Determinants of Distribution of the National Income.” Econometrica 6(2): 97-112.
Kalecki, M. (1971). “Class Struggle and the Distribution of National Income.” Kyklos 24(1): 1-9.
Keen, S. (1995). “Finance and Economic Breakdown: Modeling Minsky’s ‘Financial Instability Hypothesis.’.” Journal of Post Keynesian Economics 17(4): 607-635.
Keynes, J. M. (1936). The general theory of employment, interest and money. London, Macmillan.
Kriesler, P. (1988). “Kalecki’s Pricing Theory Revisited.” Journal of Post Keynesian Economics 11(1): 108-130.
Krugman, P. (2012). End this Depression Now! New York, W.W. Norton.
Kumhof, M. and Z. Jakab (2015). Banks are not intermediaries of loanable funds – and why this matters. Working Paper. London, Bank of England.
Kumhof, M., R. Rancière, et al. (2015). “Inequality, Leverage, and Crises.” The American Economic Review 105(3): 1217-1245.
Lorenz, E. N. (1963). “Deterministic Nonperiodic Flow.” Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences 20(2): 130-141.
Marx, K. (1852). The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte. Moscow, Progress Publishers.
Marx, K. (1867). Capital. Moscow, Progress Press.
McLeay, M., A. Radia, et al. (2014). “Money creation in the modern economy.” Bank of England Quarterly Bulletin 2014 Q1: 14-27.
Minsky, H. P. (1957). “Monetary Systems and Accelerator Models.” The American Economic Review 47(6): 860-883.
Minsky, H. P. (1982). Can “it” happen again? : essays on instability and finance. Armonk, N.Y., M.E. Sharpe.
Moore, B. J. (1979). “The Endogenous Money Stock.” Journal of Post Keynesian Economics 2(1): 49-70.
Moore, B. J. (1988). “The Endogenous Money Supply.” Journal of Post Keynesian Economics 10(3): 372-385.
Moore, B. J. (1988). Horizontalists and Verticalists: The Macroeconomics of Credit Money. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Phillips, A. W. (1954). “Stabilisation Policy in a Closed Economy.” The Economic Journal 64(254): 290-323.
Phillips, A. W. (1958). “The Relation between Unemployment and the Rate of Change of Money Wage Rates in the United Kingdom, 1861-1957.” Economica 25(100): 283-299.
Piketty, T. (2014). Capital in the Twenty-First Century. Harvard, Harvard College.
Pomeau, Y. and P. Manneville (1980). “Intermittent transition to turbulence in dissipative dynamical systems.” Communications in Mathematical Physics 74: 189-197.
Roberts, A. (2012). America’s first Great Depression economic crisis and political disorder after the Panic of 1837 / Alasdair Roberts. Ithaca
London, Ithaca : Cornell University Press.
Rochon, L.-P. (1999). “The Creation and Circulation of Endogenous Money: A Circuit Dynamique Approach.” Journal of Economic Issues 33(1): 1-21.
Rosser, J. B. (1999). Chaos Theory. Encyclopedia of Political Economy. P. A. O’Hara. London, Routledge. 2: 81-83.
Santos, C. H. D. and A. C. Macedo e Silva (2009). ‘Revisiting (and Connecting) Marglin-Bhaduri and Minsky–An SFC Look at Financialization and Profit-led Growth’, Levy Economics Institute, The, Economics Working Paper Archive.
Schularick, M. and A. M. Taylor (2012). “Credit Booms Gone Bust: Monetary Policy, Leverage Cycles, and Financial Crises, 1870-2008.” American Economic Review 102(2): 1029-1061.
Sharpe, W. F. (1964). “Capital Asset Prices: A Theory of Market Equilibrium under Conditions of Risk.” The Journal of Finance 19(3): 425-442.
Sonnenschein, H. (1972). “Market Excess Demand Functions.” Econometrica 40(3): 549-563.
Sonnenschein, H. (1973). “Do Walras’ Identity and Continuity Characterize the Class of Community Excess Demand Functions?” Journal of Economic Theory 6(4): 345-354.
Taylor, L. and S. A. O’Connell (1985). “A Minsky Crisis.” Quarterly Journal of Economics 100(5): 871-885.
Tymoigne, E. (2006). ‘The Minskyan System, Part III: System Dynamics Modeling of a Stock Flow-Consistent Minskyan Model’, Levy Economics Institute, The, Economics Working Paper Archive.
Vague, R. (2019). A Brief History of Doom: Two Hundred Years of Financial Crises. Philadelphia, University of Pennsylvania Press.
Wray, L. R. (2019). “Response to Doug Henwood’s Trolling in Jacobin.” New Economic Perspectives http://neweconomicperspectives.org/2019/02/response-to-doug-henwoods-trolling-in-jacobin.html.
Zhou, X. and C. D. Carroll (2012). “Dynamics of Wealth and Consumption: New and Improved Measures for U.S. States.” B.E. Journal of Macroeconomics 12(2).
.