Global Economic Intersection
Advertisement
  • Home
  • Economics
  • Finance
  • Politics
  • Investments
    • Invest in Amazon $250
  • Cryptocurrency
    • Best Bitcoin Accounts
    • Bitcoin Robot
      • Quantum AI
      • Bitcoin Era
      • Bitcoin Aussie System
      • Bitcoin Profit
      • Bitcoin Code
      • eKrona Cryptocurrency
      • Bitcoin Up
      • Bitcoin Prime
      • Yuan Pay Group
      • Immediate Profit
      • BitQH
      • Bitcoin Loophole
      • Crypto Boom
      • Bitcoin Treasure
      • Bitcoin Lucro
      • Bitcoin System
      • Oil Profit
      • The News Spy
      • Bitcoin Buyer
      • Bitcoin Inform
      • Immediate Edge
      • Bitcoin Evolution
      • Cryptohopper
      • Ethereum Trader
      • BitQL
      • Quantum Code
      • Bitcoin Revolution
      • British Trade Platform
      • British Bitcoin Profit
    • Bitcoin Reddit
    • Celebrities
      • Dr. Chris Brown Bitcoin
      • Teeka Tiwari Bitcoin
      • Russell Brand Bitcoin
      • Holly Willoughby Bitcoin
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Economics
  • Finance
  • Politics
  • Investments
    • Invest in Amazon $250
  • Cryptocurrency
    • Best Bitcoin Accounts
    • Bitcoin Robot
      • Quantum AI
      • Bitcoin Era
      • Bitcoin Aussie System
      • Bitcoin Profit
      • Bitcoin Code
      • eKrona Cryptocurrency
      • Bitcoin Up
      • Bitcoin Prime
      • Yuan Pay Group
      • Immediate Profit
      • BitQH
      • Bitcoin Loophole
      • Crypto Boom
      • Bitcoin Treasure
      • Bitcoin Lucro
      • Bitcoin System
      • Oil Profit
      • The News Spy
      • Bitcoin Buyer
      • Bitcoin Inform
      • Immediate Edge
      • Bitcoin Evolution
      • Cryptohopper
      • Ethereum Trader
      • BitQL
      • Quantum Code
      • Bitcoin Revolution
      • British Trade Platform
      • British Bitcoin Profit
    • Bitcoin Reddit
    • Celebrities
      • Dr. Chris Brown Bitcoin
      • Teeka Tiwari Bitcoin
      • Russell Brand Bitcoin
      • Holly Willoughby Bitcoin
No Result
View All Result
Global Economic Intersection
No Result
View All Result

Lessons from The Forgotten Depression

admin by admin
December 11, 2014
in Uncategorized
0
0
SHARES
16
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

A Book Review

by Chris Mayer, Daily Reckoning

[“History, n. An account, mostly false, of events mostly unimportant, which are brought about by rulers mostly knaves and soldiers mostly fools.” – Ambrose Bierce, The Devil’s Dictionary]

Jim Grant’s The Forgotten Depression is a history, and as with all history, it has an agenda. Here Grant puts forward the thesis that the 1921 crash cured itself. The economic ship of state righted itself without aid from government bailouts, stimulus and the like. The implied lesson is that perhaps we moderns would be wise to follow suit.

Whether or not you believe his thesis is beside the point of what follows. But I will say this about drawing lessons from history: Don’t.

I don’t quite go all the way with Henry Ford when he declared, “History is bunk!” But I do think history proves virtually nothing. It is a tangle of details that needs a human being to sort it into a tale. And that tale will be reflective of the human being doing the sorting. All history is a kind of autobiography.

The historian sees what he wants to see. Objectivity is a phantom. Truth, as far as history goes, is elusive. There is only perspective and what the historian chooses to leave out.

A few simple thought experiments will show how I think about it. What caused the American Revolution? When did it begin, exactly? Why, on that day in July, in that year, 1776, did those American rebels declare independence? It is not so easy to answer. There are many interpretations. Final causes remain a matter of debate.

The same goes for almost any historical event of reasonable complexity. Even small questions remain somehow mysterious. Why did the market crash in October 1987? Theories abound, but I find them all on the level of speculation. There is no good answer why it had to happen on that day, in that year. Why not the next month or the previous month? Why 1987?

And so I look at history with the eye of someone transacting with a shady merchant in Istanbul’s famed bazaar. I don’t trust a thing he says. (Bierce was on to something.)

History can rarely, if ever, prove anything – the efforts of historians notwithstanding. Grant is not unaware of the historian’s conceit. At one point, addressing the idea that it is best to leave an economy to heal itself, he writes:

“Whatever might be said about that proposition in general, the American experience in 1920-21 and 1929-33 does not disprove it.”

Agreed. As Karl Popper taught, there are only provisional truths, truths that have yet to be falsified. History’s particular challenge is that we can’t repeat the experiment. It is impossible to roll back the tape, change one detail and see what happens. Therefore, one can only guess.

As skeptical as I am about history, I still love the subject. I still draw insights from history, but of a different kind than most. And so it is with Grant’s book. I think it teaches history’s best lesson: No one knows what’s coming next.

Though it is not the focus the author intended, Grant’s history shows again and again how life humbles us all. I give you four anecdotes from the book. (I could’ve chosen more.)

    • The Income Tax

      In 1913, a Progressive congressman proposes an income tax amendment. The proposed tax rate topped out at 68% on incomes above a million dollars. Grant quotes The New York Times of the day: “The amendment was, of course, beaten.”

      It is the “of course” that resonates. No way, contemporary thinking went, would that ever pass.

      Yet by 1918, the U.S. Treasury was taking 77% of incomes above $1 million.

        • National City’s Mistake

          And here is another revealing anecdote.

          National City Bank. Conservative. Safe. Enormously profitable. And by 1905, the nation’s largest bank.

          “It was not infallible,” Grant writes. On the eve of the Bolshevik Revolution of 1917, City was busy building branches, gathering Russian deposits and investing in Russian bonds.

          Grant quotes Frank Vanderlip, second in command at the bank: “Of all the foreign countries, there is none that offers a more promising outlook than Russia.” That was in 1916. One year later, it was game over.

            • World War I Surprised the Market

              World War I was a total surprise to the market. “To judge by the action of the world’s stock market, not even the money men saw it coming,” Grant writes. More than a surprise, contemporaries seemed to think such a general war was not even possible.

              Grant wrote:

              “As the impossible proceeded to unfold, the belligerents abandoned the gold standard, declared debt moratoria and closed stock exchanges.”

              The war was one of the great disasters of that century. And no one saw it coming.


              What is the Income Play Rich Investors Love? (Hint: It’s Tax-Free)


              As I say, history teaches humility. That is its first and greatest lesson.

                • The Unexpected Post-WWI Boom

                  One more: There is the postwar boom in 1919. WWI was over, and everyone thought the market and economy would suffer. Yet the economy boomed.

                  Grant wrote:

                  “Doomsayers could hardly believe their eyes, Surely, they reasoned, a postwar boom was a contradiction in terms. What was needed – and what was, on form, inevitable – was a bust.”

                  They were wrong… for a while.

                  The 1921 Depression

                  When the 1921 depression did come, it was nasty. To show this, we can use a variety of statistics. Here we face yet another problem. Which statistics? Some are better than others.

                  Gross national product, for example, fell 24% from 1920-21. But that is a horrible abstraction. What is GNP? It is something made up. And anyway, you have to adjust it for changes in the value of money. Then you open another box of problems. What was the change in the value of money? Or, as we more commonly pose the question: What was the inflation (or deflation) rate?

                  The problem again is that inflation and deflation are ideas in the mind. They are not real. They are not something we can just grab. They are assumptions. They are ideas people create. As with gross national product, they are a guess.

                  Even unemployment is hard to figure. Grant writes that “a crude measure of unemployment” might indicate a 15.3% rate in 1921. But he adds many caveats about what that figure includes and doesn’t include. “The data are, at best, indicative,” he writes. And I would agree heartily on that point.

                  In tending to his statistical portrait, I was glad to see Grant cite the economist Oskar Morgenstern. He is the author of one of my favorite economic essays, “Qui Numerare Incipit Errare Incipit” (a Roman maxim meaning “He who begins to count begins to err”). Morgenstern makes a convincing case that economic statistics are guesses with wide error rates, and should be treated as such.

                  Nonetheless, some stats are concrete, where others are abstract. Auto production is concrete. It fell 23% in 1920-21. The number of companies reporting a profit in excess of $100,000 – also a concrete figure – fell by 45%. Commercial failures tripled from 1919-21, to 19,652. These kinds of figures are more tangible. They all paint a portrait of a harrowing depression.

                  The stock market, too, draws a clean picture. The Dow Jones industrial average hit a high in January 1920, at 109.88. By September, it was 88.63 – a drop of 19%. By Dec. 21, it was 66.75 – a drop of 39% drop from the high.

                  It was rough, yet the government stood by with relative indifference, as Grant tells the tale. President Harding’s inaugural address in March 1921 – with the depression already 15 months old – barely acknowledged the collapse.

                  “Neither did he propose a government plan to stop it. Rather, he seemed to trust in the curative powers of supply and demand.”

                  That view was the mainstream one at the time. Grant’s Chapter 11, titled “Not the Government’s Affair,” seems to say it all. In fact, the idea that an “economy” existed was still not yet formed. It would have to wait until the 1930s. Today, we talk about the economy as if it were a real thing, with a life and health of its own. (And we are worse off because of it.) People before 1930 did not think in such terms.

                  Thus, Grant:

                  “As far as the political-economic mind of 1920 was concerned, there was no ‘U.S. economy.’ And as the economic totality was yet unimagined, so too was the government’s role in directing, managing and stimulating it.”

                  The reward for such inaction, he says, was that the depression was over in 18 months.  Grant concludes:

                  “The depression of 1920-21 was terrible in its own way. In comparison to what was to follow, it was also, in its own way, a triumph.”

                  Perhaps. I’m an anti-government man myself, in the tradition of H.L. Mencken and Albert Jay Nock, of Henry David Thoreau and Lysander Spooner. So I know how I would like to read the events of 1920-21. But with history, you can never really know… and that is its greatest lesson.

                  In any case, if you enjoy financial history, you will enjoy Grant’s book.

                  Previous Post

                  Financial System Inquiry: Expert Reaction

                  Next Post

                  The Multinational Industries That Bribe The Most

                  Related Posts

                  Bitcoin Flirts With $24K, How High Will It Go?
                  Economics

                  Bitcoin Flirts With $24K, How High Will It Go?

                  by John Wanguba
                  February 3, 2023
                  Venezuela's PDVSA Toughens Oil Prepayment Terms
                  Business

                  Venezuela’s PDVSA Toughens Oil Prepayment Terms

                  by John Wanguba
                  February 2, 2023
                  German Economy Unexpectedly Contracts In Q4, Renewing Recession Fears
                  Economics

                  German Economy Unexpectedly Contracts In Q4, Renewing Recession Fears

                  by John Wanguba
                  February 2, 2023
                  Judge Dismisses Proposed Class-Action Suit Claiming Coinbase Securities Sales
                  Business

                  Judge Dismisses Proposed Class-Action Suit Claiming Coinbase Securities Sales

                  by John Wanguba
                  February 2, 2023
                  Aesop Targeted In $2bn Bidding War Between French Groups
                  Business

                  Aesop Targeted In $2bn Bidding War Between French Groups

                  by John Wanguba
                  February 1, 2023
                  Next Post

                  The Multinational Industries That Bribe The Most

                  Leave a Reply Cancel reply

                  Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

                  Browse by Category

                  • Business
                  • Econ Intersect News
                  • Economics
                  • Finance
                  • Politics
                  • Uncategorized

                  Browse by Tags

                  adoption altcoins banking banks Binance Bitcoin Bitcoin adoption Bitcoin market Bitcoin mining blockchain BTC business China crypto crypto adoption cryptocurrency crypto exchange crypto market crypto regulation decentralized finance DeFi Elon Musk ETH Ethereum Europe finance FTX inflation investment market analysis markets Metaverse mining NFT nonfungible tokens oil market price analysis recession regulation Russia technology Tesla the UK the US Twitter

                  Archives

                  • February 2023
                  • January 2023
                  • December 2022
                  • November 2022
                  • October 2022
                  • September 2022
                  • August 2022
                  • July 2022
                  • June 2022
                  • May 2022
                  • April 2022
                  • March 2022
                  • February 2022
                  • January 2022
                  • December 2021
                  • November 2021
                  • October 2021
                  • September 2021
                  • August 2021
                  • July 2021
                  • June 2021
                  • May 2021
                  • April 2021
                  • March 2021
                  • February 2021
                  • January 2021
                  • December 2020
                  • November 2020
                  • October 2020
                  • September 2020
                  • August 2020
                  • July 2020
                  • June 2020
                  • May 2020
                  • April 2020
                  • March 2020
                  • February 2020
                  • January 2020
                  • December 2019
                  • November 2019
                  • October 2019
                  • September 2019
                  • August 2019
                  • July 2019
                  • June 2019
                  • May 2019
                  • April 2019
                  • March 2019
                  • February 2019
                  • January 2019
                  • December 2018
                  • November 2018
                  • October 2018
                  • September 2018
                  • August 2018
                  • July 2018
                  • June 2018
                  • May 2018
                  • April 2018
                  • March 2018
                  • February 2018
                  • January 2018
                  • December 2017
                  • November 2017
                  • October 2017
                  • September 2017
                  • August 2017
                  • July 2017
                  • June 2017
                  • May 2017
                  • April 2017
                  • March 2017
                  • February 2017
                  • January 2017
                  • December 2016
                  • November 2016
                  • October 2016
                  • September 2016
                  • August 2016
                  • July 2016
                  • June 2016
                  • May 2016
                  • April 2016
                  • March 2016
                  • February 2016
                  • January 2016
                  • December 2015
                  • November 2015
                  • October 2015
                  • September 2015
                  • August 2015
                  • July 2015
                  • June 2015
                  • May 2015
                  • April 2015
                  • March 2015
                  • February 2015
                  • January 2015
                  • December 2014
                  • November 2014
                  • October 2014
                  • September 2014
                  • August 2014
                  • July 2014
                  • June 2014
                  • May 2014
                  • April 2014
                  • March 2014
                  • February 2014
                  • January 2014
                  • December 2013
                  • November 2013
                  • October 2013
                  • September 2013
                  • August 2013
                  • July 2013
                  • June 2013
                  • May 2013
                  • April 2013
                  • March 2013
                  • February 2013
                  • January 2013
                  • December 2012
                  • November 2012
                  • October 2012
                  • September 2012
                  • August 2012
                  • July 2012
                  • June 2012
                  • May 2012
                  • April 2012
                  • March 2012
                  • February 2012
                  • January 2012
                  • December 2011
                  • November 2011
                  • October 2011
                  • September 2011
                  • August 2011
                  • July 2011
                  • June 2011
                  • May 2011
                  • April 2011
                  • March 2011
                  • February 2011
                  • January 2011
                  • December 2010
                  • August 2010
                  • August 2009

                  Categories

                  • Business
                  • Econ Intersect News
                  • Economics
                  • Finance
                  • Politics
                  • Uncategorized
                  Global Economic Intersection

                  After nearly 11 years of 24/7/365 operation, Global Economic Intersection co-founders Steven Hansen and John Lounsbury are retiring. The new owner, a global media company in London, is in the process of completing the set-up of Global Economic Intersection files in their system and publishing platform. The official website ownership transfer took place on 24 August.

                  Categories

                  • Business
                  • Econ Intersect News
                  • Economics
                  • Finance
                  • Politics
                  • Uncategorized

                  Recent Posts

                  • Bitcoin Flirts With $24K, How High Will It Go?
                  • Venezuela’s PDVSA Toughens Oil Prepayment Terms
                  • German Economy Unexpectedly Contracts In Q4, Renewing Recession Fears

                  © Copyright 2021 EconIntersect - Economic news, analysis and opinion.

                  No Result
                  View All Result
                  • Home
                  • Contact Us
                  • Bitcoin Robot
                    • Bitcoin Profit
                    • Bitcoin Code
                    • Quantum AI
                    • eKrona Cryptocurrency
                    • Bitcoin Up
                    • Bitcoin Prime
                    • Yuan Pay Group
                    • Immediate Profit
                    • BitIQ
                    • Bitcoin Loophole
                    • Crypto Boom
                    • Bitcoin Era
                    • Bitcoin Treasure
                    • Bitcoin Lucro
                    • Bitcoin System
                    • Oil Profit
                    • The News Spy
                    • British Bitcoin Profit
                    • Bitcoin Trader
                  • Bitcoin Reddit

                  © Copyright 2021 EconIntersect - Economic news, analysis and opinion.

                  en English
                  ar Arabicbg Bulgarianda Danishnl Dutchen Englishfi Finnishfr Frenchde Germanel Greekit Italianja Japaneselv Latvianno Norwegianpl Polishpt Portuguesero Romanianes Spanishsv Swedish