Editor’s Note:This article is republished with permission of LEAP/E2020. See end of article for credits.
– Public announcement GEAB N°68 (October 16, 2012) –
For several months we have anticipated a major shock for the economy and global political stability for Autumn 2012. We are maintaining this “Red Alert” and will take stock mid-November 2012, at the same time as our annual analysis of the 2013 “risk-countries”, and on the state of the world at this time.
These last few weeks, as predicted by our team, the world geopolitical situation has rapidly deteriorated: the Syrian conflict has become a regional conflict in which the major powers are now trying not to be drawn in beyond the limits that they have set (1); to the North of the Sahel (Mali, Niger, …) a new military confrontation between Islamists and the West is in the offing (2); the China Sea has been turned into zone of “tepid” conflicts across the board with Japan and China in the middle of brewing chaos (3); the major world economies are all entering recession (4); social unrest is growing just like tax pressure,… and there is no more liquidity available (even QE has an effectiveness in freefall (5)) as was still the case in 2009.
In this issue, our team thus takes stock of Western real estate prospects out to 2013 and adds a special anticipation “Netherlands Real Estate” due to the real estate crash in progress in this country. At the same time we continue to explore the socio-political consequences for 2013 of the increasing unrest in public opinion, concentrating here on the United States (6). Finally, after a review and a schedule of the main trends for the next few months, we expand on our recommendations concerning real estate, gold and the stock exchanges.
% Impact of the Fed’s QE on US liquidity over 3 months (blue), 6 months (red), 1 year (green) and 2 years (violet) – Source: Hussman Funds, 09/2012
In addition to the extract of part of our analyses on the American real estate, which really confirms the entry of the Western property market into a long-term depression, we have chosen, in this GEAB N°68 press release, to present a number of graphs illustrating the smokescreen and manipulatory character of US economic statistics.
Our team has appreciated the fact that the electoral argument over the “official” US unemployment figures for September 2012 (a 0.4% fall) has allowed a far-reaching debate in the principal media on the “strange methods of calculation” of the US Ministry of Employment. It’s not the only one to massage the numbers but given the international media importance granted to these results, it appears useful that a greater number of players should be aware of it; and not only the enlightened readers of the GEAB and other teaching sites.
As regards China, the political transition in progress is proceeding with difficulty due to the global economic crisis which has finally caught up with the country (12) (and all the BRICS (13)) and of the need to invent a new course for the country’s strategy in order to face the double internal pressure of the risk of social explosion (we will return to this in detail in the November issue of the GEAB) and of regional and global geopolitical positioning. It’s not only the United States which has radically changed since 1990/2000!
The world order’s third major pillar (and in fact perhaps the most constructive for the future) is the European Union or, more exactly, Euroland. As anticipated by LEAP/E2020, the Eurozone is the only bearer of good news this Autumn. Of course, it’s very strongly overshadowed in the short run by the economic and budgetary consequences of the global systemic crisis (unemployment, recession, austerity,…), but for the medium to long term Euroland has finally committed itself to a “road which leads somewhere” after months of political impotence: powerful instruments are now available, the common political will to exit together (14) has finally gained a foothold (15) (as each Member State feels the impact of the crisis henceforth).
In terms of a schedule, LEAP/E2020 estimates that from now the timing is very clear:
. by the end of November 2012, the United States and China are each entering a double phase of historical domestic socio-political tensions before having to come to terms with the end of the period of “peaceful economic and commercial coexistence” of these last decades
. by December 2012, Euroland exits, jogging along, as it usually does, from the “Euro crisis” and finds itself facing the triple challenge of its economic revival against the background of a global crisis, its institutional structuring against a background of imperative democratization (16) and, coupled with that, the long term settlement of the British problem (in fact 26 versus 1) (17).
US retail gasoline sales (1984-2012) (In thousands of Gallons per day) – Source: US Dpt of Energy, 09/2012
United States, « recovery » or smokescreen?
The media would have us believe in a recovery in the US real estate market, based mainly on the Case-Shiller index shown on the chart below.
Case-Shiller National Index of US real estate prices, 2005-2012 – Source: S&P/Case-Shiller
First, interest rates are at historically low levels (currently 3.39% for a fixed rate 30 year loan according toCNNmoney, which, on the one hand, allows some households, even largely insolvent, to return to the property market but, on the other and especially, allows investors to make good deals buying properties on the cheap repossessed by the banks. These transactions automatically increase prices. One will note all the same that interest rates have been extremely low for several years now and that the effect is only being felt now, a sign of the of the various players fragility and thus of the “recovery”. Unfortunately, interest rates at this level in no way reflects the health of the US economy and is only kept at that level thanks to the Fed’s repurchase of Treasury Bonds. In normal times, the various public plans of support for the economy should, for that matter, have had a much more marked upwards impact on real estate prices.
The second reason comes from the shortage organized by the banks which don’t want to resell houses seized at market prices to save their balance sheets. In fact, 90% of the foreclosures are retained by the banks (18). Millions of houses which will soon have to come on the market and which will lower prices; but for the moment the organized retention limits supply and creates a shortage pushing up prices.
And yet, it’s really the repossessions which reveal the real estate sector’s poor health in the United States. After a pause due to the banks’ robo signing scandal, the number of repossessions is on the rise again (we are talking of about three million repossessions a year). In fact, to understand the reality of the American property market, is a game just as cynical as it’s instructive: using the list of the largest American big cities (except New York) onWikipedia, and counting the proportion of repossessions advertised in these cities on a website like Trulia (19), in spite of the many houses held on the banks’ balance sheets the conclusion is alarming: in the ten biggest US cities after New York, the proportion of adverts to repossessions is in the order of 56% (20), with cities like Los Angeles (the United States’ second city) or Chicago (the third) having a proportion of foreclosures of around 67%, not to mention, of course, Detroit or Miami where it culminates around 75%. One also notices that adverts where the price is falling are much more numerous than those where it is rising. Only New York seems to have a dynamic market, with almost no foreclosures and rising.
No more than in 2009, it shouldn’t be believed that the rise is lasting. It’s just another United States trick which one is now used to.
And like all tricks, once understood, they reveal a much worse reality than one imagined… opening the door to panic! Remember Lehman Brothers… in a few hours the world moved from “normal” to “Red Alert” mode!
(2) Sign of a growing confusion in the alliances used by the West; in Syria, Saudi Arabia and Qatar is in the front line of the “pro-Western” forces in war against the Assad regime; North of the Sahel, on the contrary they arm the rebels who will face the soldiers of the African forces supported by NATO. The wide geostrategic variations of this type are not long-lasting… except to think that Saudi petrodollars can indefinitely “keep Washington”, as Qatar is trying to do with France and as Kuwait and Dubai has already done with the United Kingdom. Source: France 24, 29/09/2012
(3) And these “tepid” conflicts have already had quite tangible and painful consequences: wounded at the time of the anti-Japanese riots, collapse of certain major economic activities between two of the principal world economic and commercial powers (China and Japan) especially as regards the automotive industry, tourism, electronics, public construction,…. the bill is big and lasting… and hasn’t yet impacted the statistics.
(5) Even the Fed board members now admit that they don’t really understand the US economic situation. Source: Les Echos, 20/09/2012
(6) Source: The Hill, 28/09/2012
(7) Source: Deutsche Welle, 20/09/2012
(8) Source: New York Times, 24/09/2012
(9) Tokyo is increasingly wondering what is the “real added value” of 10/20 years of complete alignment with Washington. Ten/twenty years are the minimum deadlines to reflect on and implement any major modification to this kind of historical partnership…. and imposing difficult decisions in the very short-term. It’s not surprising that Japanese nationalists are adding some to the current conflicts over the islands! Source: Le Monde, 26/09/2012; Caixin, 24/09/2012
(10) Source: Deutsche Welle, 04/10/2012
(11) The Dollar is in the process of losing its oil currency status for China, to the benefit of the Yuan Source: The Examiner, 12/09/2012
(13) Source: CNBC, 04/10/2012
(15) As we had anticipated and contrary to the prevailing discussions on the end of the Euro, the exit of Greece… and other madness which proves, if it were still needed, that the economists and other experts of this craft, should really develop their multidisciplinary knowledge in particular in politics, geopolitics, forecasting and the working of networks and complex systems. They could also usefully stop “barking” for more or less concealed financial economic interests. It’s not only in the sphere of health and drug testing that conflicts of interests are frequent. Last remark on this subject: to continue to give the Nobel Prize for economics to American specialists, as has just been done again, is frankly proof that the whole discipline is blind. The current crisis marks the complete failure of prevailing economic thinking since 1945 and nevertheless one continues to validate the work from universities and experts who have not stopped being wrong for over 60 years. Can one imagine such a situation in physics, in chemistry,…? Rewarding scientists who never produce results? That illustrates at what point it’s really a Nobel Prize for ideology like that for peace (Obama, EU,…).
(18) Source: AOL real estate, 13/07/2012
(19) One of the big real estate websites and which allows one to choose only repossession adverts and, therefore, know the number.
(20) 88,200 repossessions out of 157,500 adverts.
Other Posts from this Author:
|analysis blog||opinion blog|
Editor’s Note: This article is a Global Europe Anticipation Bulletin (GEAB No. 67) from think-tank LEAP/Europe 2020, published in partnership with the Dutch foundation GEFIRA. As such, their aim is to provide state-of-the-art analysis of geo-political anticipation centered around the study and follow-up of the global systemic crisis, itself focused on the evolution of the dollar and of the US economy, and their impact on international economy and financial markets, all that seen from a European perspective.