Variable Annuities Scheme to Profit from Imminent Deaths of Terminal Patients

from the Securities Exchange Commission (SEC)

The Securities and Exchange Commission today announced enforcement actions against a pair of brokers, an investment advisory firm, and several others involved in a variable annuities scheme to profit from the imminent deaths of terminally ill patients in nursing homes and hospice care.

Variable annuities are designed to serve as long-term investment vehicles, typically to provide income at retirement. Common features are a death benefit paid to the annuity’s beneficiary (typically a spouse or child) if the annuitant dies, and a bonus credit that the annuity issuer adds to the contract value based on a specified percentage of purchase payments. The SEC Enforcement Division alleges that Michael A. Horowitz, a broker who lives in Los Angeles, developed an illicit strategy to exploit these benefits. He recruited others to help him obtain personal health and identifying information of terminally ill patients in southern California and Chicago. Anticipating they would soon die, Horowitz sold variable annuities contracts with death benefit and bonus credit features to wealthy investors, and he designated the patients as annuitants whose death would trigger a benefit payout. Horowitz marketed these annuities as opportunities for investors to reap short-term investment gains. When the annuitants died, the investors collected death benefit payouts.

The SEC Enforcement Division alleges that Horowitz enlisted another brokerMoshe Marc Cohen of Brooklyn, N.Y., and they each deceived their own brokerage firms to obtain the approvals they needed to sell the annuities. They falsified various broker-dealer forms used by firms to conduct investment suitability reviews. As a result of the fraudulent practices used in the scheme, some insurance companies unwittingly issued variable annuities that they would not otherwise have sold. Horowitz and Cohen, meanwhile, generated more than $1 million in sales commissions.

Agreeing to settle the SEC’s charges are four non-brokers and a New York-based investment advisory firm recruited into the scheme. Also agreeing to settlements are two other brokers who are charged with causing books-and-records violations related to annuities sold through the scheme. A combined total of more than $4.5 million will be paid in the settlements. The SEC’s litigation continues against Horowitz and Cohen. Said Julie M. Riewe, co-chief of the SEC Enforcement Division’s Asset Management Unit:

This was a calculated fraud exploiting terminally ill patients. Michael Horowitz and others stole their most private information for personal monetary gain.

According to the SEC’s orders instituting administrative proceedings, the scheme began in 2007 and continued into 2008. Horowitz agreed to compensate Harold Ten of Los Angeles and Menachem “Mark” Berger of Chicago for identifying terminally ill patients to be used as annuitants. Berger, in turn, recruited Debra Flowers of Chicago into the scheme and compensated her directly. Through the use of a purported charity and other forms of deception, Ten, Berger, and Flowers obtained confidential health data about patients for Horowitz.

According to the SEC’s orders, after selling millions of dollars in variable annuities to individual investors, Horowitz still desired to generate greater capital into the scheme. Searching for a large source of financing, he began pitching his scheme to institutional investors. A pooled investment vehicle and its adviser BDL Manager LLC were created in late 2007 in order to facilitate institutional investment in variable annuities through the use of nominees. Commodities traderHoward Feder, who lives in Woodmere, N.Y., became each firm’s sole principal. Feder and BDL Manager fraudulently secured broker-dealer approvals of more than $56 million in annuities sold through Horowitz’s scheme. Feder furnished the brokers with blank forms signed by the nominees enabling the brokers to complete the forms with false statements indicating that the nominees did not intend to access their investments for many years. Feder understood that the purpose of Horowitz’s scheme was to designate terminally ill patients as annuitants in the expectation that their deaths would result in short-term lucrative payouts. BDL Group received more than $1.5 million in proceeds from its investment in the annuities.

The order against Horowitz and Cohen alleges that they willfully violated the antifraud provisions of the Securities Act of 1933 and the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and they willfully aided and abetted and caused violations of the Exchange Act’s books-and-records provisions. Horowitz also acted as an unregistered broker.

Ten, Berger, Flowers, Feder, and BDL Manager consented to SEC orders finding that they willfully violated Section 10(b) of the Exchange Act and Rule 10b-5. They neither admitted nor denied the findings and agreed to cease and desist from future violations. The individuals agreed to securities industry or penny stock bars as well as the following monetary sanctions:

• Ten agreed to pay disgorgement of $181,147.64, prejudgment interest of $20,858.80, and a penalty of $90,000.
• Berger agreed to pay disgorgement of $119,000, prejudgment interest of $11,579.61, and a penalty of $100,000.
• Feder agreed to pay a penalty of $130,000.
• BDL Manager agreed to pay disgorgement of $1,550,565.55, prejudgment interest of $196,608.97, and a penalty of $1,550,565.55.

The SEC’s order against Richard Horowitz and Marc Firestone finds that they negligently allowed point-of-sale forms for 12 annuities in the scheme to be submitted to their firm with inaccurately overstated answers to the form’s question asking how soon the customer intended to access his or her investment. These inaccurate answers led to each annuity’s issuance, and Horowitz and Firestone were each paid commissions.

Richard Horowitz and Firestone consented to the order finding that they caused their firm to violate Section 17(a) of the Exchange Act and Rule 17a-3. Without admitting or denying the findings, they agreed to cease and desist from committing or causing future violations of those provisions as well as the following monetary sanctions:

• Horowitz agreed to pay disgorgement of $292,767.89, prejudgment interest of $36,512.20, and a penalty of $40,800.
• Firestone agreed to pay disgorgement of $127,853.20, prejudgment interest of $17,140.89, and a penalty of $40,800.

The SEC’s investigation was conducted by Marilyn Ampolsk, Peter Haggerty, Jeremiah Williams, and Anthony Kelly of the Enforcement Division’s Asset Management Unit along with Christopher Mathews and J. Lee Buck II. The SEC’s litigation will be led by Dean M. Conway.