Web of Lies, Fake Issues and Myths

April 17th, 2012
in Op Ed

by Guest Author Fabius Maximus

Summary: Our government’s debt grows, imperiling not just its solvency but our very self-confidence in ourselves, and in our political regime. Can we reform before the end? Read this essay to learn the answer. And rejoice!

lady-liberty-ashamedSMALLOriginal Title: Fear not! America will not fall due to its citizen’s imprudence. We’ve found a sure solution.

Read and learn from the money paragraph of “Why Democracies Fail”, often attributed to Alexander Fraser Tytler (Lord Woodhouselee, 1747–1813), a Scottish attorney:

A democracy cannot exist as a permanent form of government. It can only exist until the voters discover that they can vote themselves largesse from the public treasury. From that moment on, the majority always votes for the candidates promising the most benefits from the public treasury with the result that a democracy always collapses over loose fiscal policy, always followed by a dictatorship.

Follow up:

This is one of the legion of fake quotes circulated by conservatives (details here), part of their great project to enmesh American minds in a web of lies. This one is especially daft. America’s long-term deficits are driven almost entirely by our massive military spending (ie, foreign wars and belligerent foreign policy) plus tax cuts (mostly for the rich). Secondary factors are subsidies to large corporations (eg, agribusiness subsidies, give-away of mining rights on public lands, bank bailouts).

None of these are voting “themselves largesse from the public”.

This fable combines these false elements with nonsense: seeing America as a democracy dominated by public opinion, in which our ruling elites slavishly follow the people’s whims — no matter how foolish. In fact they conduct key aspects of US policy in defiance of public opinion. Some notable examples: our foreign wars (conducted long after public support faded), open borders (ie, massive immigration), plus the unpopular cuts to Social Security and Medicare proposed by our great and wise.

The deficit dominates the thinking of our ruling elites. Their lackies in Washington and on Wall Street supposedly fear the debt above all other things — but not so much that they advocate rasing taxes back towards their levels during America’s great post-WWII boom years.  For details see

The deficit is a fake issue in a larger sense.  One searches in vain for a plutocrat-dominated political regime that died through imprudent domestic spending. The spectre of bankruptcy only serves as a wedge to force cutbacks in wasteful spending (ie, on the 99%).  As our plutocrats’ hold grows firmer, this fear will no longer serve a useful purpose — and the time will come to save the Republic.  For details see Our fears are unwarranted. America is in fact well-governed.

But the other well-known fake Tytler quote looks prophetic. It’s taken from a speech on 18 March 1943 by Henning Webb Prentis, Jr. (President of the Armstrong Cork Company). Most of it is the usual plutocratic fantasy history. One paragraph in particular is false as history, but might become an excellent summary of American history (source here):

The historical cycle seems to be from

1.    bondage to spiritual faith;
2.    from spiritual faith to courage;
3.    from courage to liberty;
4.    from liberty to abundance;
5.    from abundance to selfishness;
6.    from selfishness to apathy;
7.    from apathy to dependency; and
8.    from dependency back to bondage once more.

The American people appear to have evolved through this series into stages 5 and 6.  Our forefathers must weep at the prospect. It need not be so, if we will otherwise.

Mrs. Powel of Philadelphia asked Dr. Franklin “What have we got, a republic or a monarchy” “A republic, if you can keep it” replied the Doctor.
— entry of 18 September 1787 in the Papers of Dr. James McHenry on the Federal Convention of 1887 (signer the Constitution, our 3rd Secretary of War, and namesake of Fort McHenry)

For More Information: a look at America’s past

  1. Our futures seen in snippets of the past, 16 June 2008 — Great men of the past comment on our situation
  2. de Tocqueville warns us not to become weak and servile, 21 July 2008
  3. Let’s look at America in the mirror, the first step to reform, 14 August 2008
  4. Can Americans pull together? If not, why not?, 29 August 2008
  5. An important thing to remember as we start a New Year, 29 December 2008 — A great speech from Morpheus to Zion, from we too can learn
  6. A wonderful and important speech about liberty, 23 July 2009 — By Judge Learned Hand

Make a Comment

Econintersect wants your comments, data and opinion on the articles posted. You can also comment using Facebook directly using he comment block below.


  1. Joey Baluga says :

    "America’s long-term deficits are driven almost entirely by our massive military spending"

    In 2012 military spending is near its lowest level in history as a percentage of GDP. Nearly two-thirds of federal spending is social spending. Put these two together and we discover you are patently false in your repetition of the democratic socialist lines.

    Two, military and space especially have produced the first uses of the Internet, plastics, communication protocols, and advances in flight science picked up by the public airlines. The contribution to our economy by these federal programs cannot even be measured if you had a ruler to do so. REAL returns to the marketplace.

    "The deficit is a fake issue..."

    You people who presume there is a money tree somewhere will have the greatest rude awakening. Prepare for $10 heads of lettuce at the supermarket due to the spending policies of DC. Half of Europe rioting in the streets is not enough evidence for you? Your blindness is staggering.

    "the unpopular cuts to Social Security and Medicare "

    "Cuts" is a scare tactic word and has been a misnomer through our lifetimes. PROOF: There has not been a year-over-year federal spending cut since 1949. I am pretty sure there has never been a year-over-year net cut to these social programs either. Liberals in America use the term "cuts" like any good Nazi or Marxist would. There has not been a cut in our lifetimes but but every election the democratic operatives scare all the old people into thinking they're monthly checks will be cut.

    This is a free country, so you are free to hate conservatives. Hate them because they like a strong military. Hate them because of their skin color. Hate them for any reason you like. But your arguments about how to best run a country are easily shredded by the facts.

  2. ****-

    "In 2012 military spending is near its lowest level in history as a percentage of GDP. Nearly two-thirds of federal spending is social spending."

    Expressing military spending as a percentage of GDP is literally meaningless. The amount of "social spending" by the government is absurdly inflated by the inclusion of Social Security, a program that is independently financed and takes in far more than it pays out. Remove it, and military spending, at present, accounts for 48% of discretionary spending--just under half. In context, even limiting "defense spending" to the Pentagon budget alone, the U.S. accounts for nearly half the total military spending in the entire world--even if the U.S. didn't have a single ally, the defense budget is many, many times anything remotely justifiable (combined spending by the U.S. and its allies is over 80% of global military expenditures).

  3. Brian Hughes says :

    The amusing thing is that your concern is only with the attribution - somehow that's all that matters, whether it was Tytler that said it, or Toqueville, or whoever.

    I could really care less if it was Tytler or the editor of the Oklahoman - what you fail to grasp in your efforts to disprove where it came from is that it's TRUE. But then, liberals always do believe what they're told based on the source rather than the merits of the argument.

 navigate econintersect.com


Analysis Blog
News Blog
Investing Blog
Opinion Blog
Precious Metals Blog
Markets Blog
Video of the Day


Asia / Pacific
Middle East / Africa
USA Government

RSS Feeds / Social Media

Combined Econintersect Feed

Free Newsletter

Marketplace - Books & More

Economic Forecast

Content Contribution



  Top Economics Site

Investing.com Contributor TalkMarkets Contributor Finance Blogs Free PageRank Checker Active Search Results Google+

This Web Page by Steven Hansen ---- Copyright 2010 - 2018 Econintersect LLC - all rights reserved