USA Trade Deficit Exports 1.3 million Jobs

January 21st, 2011
in Op Ed

Job Wanted by Steven Hansen

In Dr. Michael Pettis Econintersect article - Currency Wars and Trade Woes but China Marches On -   he concluded:

So that leaves the U.S.  Either it can accept rising trade deficits as it absorbs the employment problems of the rest of the world, or it can move to intervene in trade.  I don’t know what it will do, but I am pretty confident that the domestic debate will intensify.  One way or the other the crisis in international trade is far from over.  In fact the day after I finished this entry the Financial Times, again, had a new headline: “Trade war looming, warns Brazil.”

The burr under my saddle is jobs.  I may leave that theme for a time but always return.  Trade deficits export jobs.  Some think it is only money on balance sheet - but it is jobs that are exported when when a country imports manufactured goods.

Follow up:

Some quick facts using unadjusted data:

  • Through November 2010 according to U.S. Census, the USA has manufactured $4.55 trillion of goods in 2010.
  • Total employment in the manufacturing industry is 11,660,000 according to the BLS.  This means that for every $1,000,000 of production in 2010, 2.56 people were employed.
  • Through November 2010 according to US Census data, the USA has exported $0.8 trillion of manufactured goods - or 17.5% of manufacturing.
  • The total import of manufactured goods through November 2010 is a little more than $1.3 trillion making the manufactured goods trade gap more than $0.5 trillion.
  • The manufacturing trade gap of $500,000,000,000 ($0.5 trillion) times 2.56 people per $1 million of manufacturing equals approximately 1.3 million jobs.

I will skip raising the 1.3 million job estimate by using the somewhat controversial jobs multipliers (that in theory means a manufacturing job lost likely causes two addition jobs being lost in the service industry).  I will even ignore that it is likely the type of jobs being exported are of higher labor content then the current mix of existing manufacturing jobs.  The 1.3 million estimate is likely significantly understated - and the real number is probably in excess of 5 million.  That is close to half of the full-time jobs lost in The Great Recession.  And this is only for 11 months of one year!!!

Trade is not about money - it is about jobs.

Market Recommendations Made This Week:

An Alternate View on Housing: 2011 May Be Homebuilders' Time to Shine - Recommended a second look at the homebuilder's sector as the backlog should turn positive in 2011.  Regardless of viewpoint on growth potential for this sector, the money bleed caused by downsizing will end this year allowing higher profits.

Economic News this Week:

Econintersect economic forecast for January 2010 pointing to a slightly improving economy.   This week the Weekly Leading Index (WLI) from ECRI continued to improve from 3.6 to 4.1 implying the business conditions six months from now might be improving.  Six months ago, the WLI was negative that December should have been slightly worse then July 2010.  This December data has been coming in fairly strong.

The Conference Board Leading Economic Index® (LEI) for the U.S. increased 1.0 percent in December to 112.4 (2004 = 100).  This indicator is also trying to look ahead six months - and has been forecasting six months ahead being better since the end of the Great Recession.  Their economists' opinions:

“While the LEI points to an economic expansion that is gaining further traction, its components still suggest the expansion path may be uneven. December’s gain was led by housing permits, the interest rate spread, initial claims for unemployment insurance and consumer expectations. The large increases in December and November show that, after a brief pause in the second quarter of 2010, the LEI is resuming the upward trend that began in March 2009.”   .......“The four-month rise suggests the economy now has some wind in its sails; however, it still faces some strong headwinds in the medium-term.  Overall economic activity is likely to continue to gain momentum in 2011.”

Initial unemployment claims in this week’s release decreased slightly.  Last week's very large not seasonally adjusted number appears to be just a blip as unadjusted claims fell over 200,000 in the current week's data.  The DOL seasonal adjustment methodology appears to have made a good call last week.

Most of the data released this week was inconsistent with Econintersect’s December forecast of slow to flat growth - and it more resembles Econintersect's January forecast.  Overall most of the December data released this week was strong.  However, the transport indicators began their improvement in December which historically foretells economic improvement.

Caveat: one month does not make a trend.

The table below itemizes the major events and analysis this week.

Weekly Economic Release Scorecard:

Item Headline Analysis
Philly Fed Business Survey
Down Slightly
Big jump in new orders and backlog
Existing Home Sales
Up MoM
Down YoY, Inventories up YoY, home prices remain relatively flat
New Residential Construction
Up 16.7% MoM
The data is an improvement on terrible
Oil Shocks and Economic Recessions

Correlates oil prices to USA recessions
Empire State Manufacturing Survey
Up slightly
Still showing manufacturing expanding
Sea Container Counts
Up 16% YoY
Record exports but import's improvements were larger
Inflation Rates

Comparing Shadowstat's data to the CPI
China and the Trade Gap

Is trade war looming?
J P Morgan

Dragons, Haircuts and the Doomsday Machine
Consumer Sentiment

Consumer and small business sentiment remains at or near levels associated with the bottoms of other recent recessions
Opinion: Global Economic Chaos 2011

Societies on the edge of socio-economic break-up

Opinion: China

Trying to guess China's direction and policy responses
Opinion: Belgium

Will the seat of the EU leave the Union?
Opinion: 2011

Cautiously optimistic on the U.S. and global economy
Opinion: Federal Reserve

What would it have been like if the Federal Reserve was not created.

Bankruptcy this week: None

Bank Failures this Week:

Make a Comment

Econintersect wants your comments, data and opinion on the articles posted.  As the internet is a "war zone" of trolls, hackers and spammers - Econintersect must balance its defences against ease of commenting.  We have joined with Livefyre to manage our comment streams.

To comment, just click the "Sign In" button at the top-left corner of the comment box below. You can create a commenting account using your favorite social network such as Twitter, Facebook, Google+, LinkedIn or Open ID - or open a Livefyre account using your email address.


  1. Lost Canyon says :

    Three zeros too many in that $0.5 trillion number up there, partner. The number you've written down is $500 trillion. Ah, what's $450 trillion, give or take -- right?

  2. admin (Member) Email says :

    Thanks for the heads up Lost Canyon. Article has been corrected.

    steven hansen

  3. Roger Erickson says :

    "Trade deficits export jobs."

    So? No problem. The bigger task is to think, not simply hold on to old jobs.

    Net jobs are lost ONLY if the labor reassigned to exporters is not re-purposed to the next great thing. There are always options, and the bigger requirement is to select the best options, not just try to hold on to the old ones, out of habit.

    When someone offers to, say, clean your house, for cheap, you hire them & re-dedicate your time to more productive activities. That's what human have always done, otherwise we would still be living hand-to-mouth, in caves & under trees.

    Let indentured exporters do old jobs. The only way forward is ... well, forward. Survivable contingency mgt never involves stasis. Moving forward means building new capability at home, NOT just preserving old jobs.

    Anyone interested in survival of their descendants, not just selling them out, will not fall for the myth of preserving their parents jobs for their grandkids, but WILL insist on creating newly productive labor that new citizen co-owners of the USA can participate in.

    Here's my suggested alternative option: sell our effing bankers, and build insanely novel REAL capability faster, not just old jobs.

    Citizens own the USA. It's not owned by the bankers who hoard fiat cash, create currency shortages, and then convince fools to sell real assets for small amounts of fiat currency.

    Sell the bankers. Invest in real invention.

  4. admin (Member) Email says :

    @Roger Erikson form John Lounsbury

    Two responses:

    1. You can only sell what someone will buy.

    2. Citizens may own the U.S. but it can be argued that they don't have the foggiest idea what to do with it. You may have seen the news item this week that almost half of college students have learned absolutely nothing after two years of college. ( This comes after high school where way more than half have learned nothing. (The latter is not based on research, just observation as a former junior college and college professor.)

    Thanks for the comment. You have a great idea but implementation may be a problem.

  5. J.D. Smith says :

    An increase in the housing market will help the builders and increase property taxes for cities, but it will not help the labor market because most of the sub-contractors the builders use hire illegal immigrants, who send most of their paycheck home to pay coyotes to bring in more of their friends and family to take more jobs. It is the same with highway and bridge building. Even the new Cowboy Stadium was build by illegals.



Analysis Blog
News Blog
Investing Blog
Opinion Blog
Precious Metals Blog
Markets Blog
Video of the Day


Asia / Pacific
Middle East / Africa
USA Government

RSS Feeds / Social Media

Combined Econintersect Feed

Free Newsletter

Marketplace - Books & More

Economic Forecast

Content Contribution



  Top Economics Site Contributor TalkMarkets Contributor Finance Blogs Free PageRank Checker Active Search Results Google+

This Web Page by Steven Hansen ---- Copyright 2010 - 2016 Econintersect LLC - all rights reserved