by Edward Hugh, Euro Watch
This months manufacturing PMI data only confirm what several months of prior surveys (and now the latest US jobs report) have been telling us, namely that growth in the developed economies is getting scarcer and scarcer, and harder and harder to come by. Following a brief brief period of stabilization, which lasted roughly from November last year to this January, conditions have been steadily deteriorating in manufacturing sectors across the planet, with the deterioration being lead by an ongoing decline in new export orders. Roped in together through the various trade channels, the worlds industrial base is now, even in the best of cases, barely eking out growth, as can be seen in the fact that the JP Morgan global index registered a mere 50.6 in May, only marginally above the 50 no change level.
As the Global report puts it, the main drag on global industry remains Europe, where the Eurozone and UK PMIs fell to three-year lows. PMIs for Germany, France, Italy, Spain, the Netherlands and Greece all signaled contractions. Ireland saw a modest expansion, while Austria edged closer to stagnation. But beyond this activity in Eastern Europe weakened, as it did in Asia and the Americas.
New business continued to contract, with the rate of contraction especially marked, according to the report, in the case of export orders. Manufacturers in Europe, China and Japan all reported reduced levels of new export business, while growth in new exports slowed sharply in the US.
With the world nervously waiting to see how the Greek election process pans out, and where the Spanish government will find the money to recapitalize the country’s banks, the slowdown in China is turning out to be a wild card, which simply sends negative feedback into an already difficult situation.
Most eyes at the present time are, however, firmly fixed on Europe, and in particular the Euro Area, where the seasonally adjusted Markit Eurozone Manufacturing PMI fell to a near three-year low of 45.1, down from 45.9 in April and little-changed from the earlier flash estimate of 45.0. The Euro Area PMI has now signaled contraction in each of the past ten months.
Ireland was the only nation to register accelerating, albeit modest, expansion, while in Austria – the other country in the Area where manufacturing conditions still improve – the PMI slipped back and closer to stagnation. All the other Euro nations covered by the survey saw contractions. PMIs for Germany, France and Spain all fell to their lowest levels since mid-2009, while the downturn in the Netherlands accelerated to its fastest in five months. In a pretty symbolic gesture, Greece moved off the bottom of the euro PMI league table for the first time since January 2010 to be replaced by Spain.
New export orders fell to the greatest extent since November last year, reflecting both slower global economic growth and lower levels of intra-Eurozone trade. Germany, Spain and Greece all reported especially marked reductions in new export orders.
The renewed decline in German activity is particularly significant, given the importance of the German economy in the Euro Area and its dependence on industry. As Tim Moore, senior economist at Markit put it in his report.
“Germany’s manufacturing output continued to lurch downwards in May, with the resilience of the first quarter now giving way to the steepest drop in production levels for almost three years. Weaker global economic conditions resulted in shrinking order inflows, especially from export markets. The latest drop in new work from abroad was the fastest for six months, which manufacturers linked to softer demand within Europe and signs of a slowdown in Asia”.
Naturally the situation in Spain is a point of particular concern, with everyone keeping their fingers crossed that the achievement of pole contraction position over Greece does not augur a wider development wherein the country is driven hurtling off along the same path. Summing up the situation in Spain, Andrew Harker, economist at Markit and author of the report, said:
“Things went from bad to worse in the Spanish manufacturing sector during May. Rates of decline in output and new orders are now faster than at any time in the past three years. The ongoing lack of demand in the sector is mainly reflective of domestic problems, but the weakness in the rest of the eurozone was also reported to have weighed on demand in May. All of this provided a further squeeze on the labour market as the rate of job shedding remained marked.”
Apart from the rather erratic readings we keep seeing on the Hungarian PMI (perhaps there is some problem with the seasonal adjustment process), the rest of the CEE countries surveyed (Poland, the Czech Republic and Turkey) all showed conditions deteriorating.
The Czech Republic is already in recession, and its all important export sector is heavily dependent on Germany, which is itself slowing. Commenting on the Czech Republic survey, Agata Urbanska, Economist, Central & Eastern Europe at HSBC, said:
“It is hard to beat the bad news conveyed by much deeper than expected GDP contraction in the first quarter of this year and in this sense the weakening PMI comes as no surprise. But the PMI index still points to downside risks in the coming quarters. The outlook for growth keeps getting worse. Higher than expected German GDP growth in 1Q12 failed to support the Czech economy while, most recently, the leading indicators, ZEW and Ifo, have deteriorated and caught-up with the weakening PMI trend. Indeed the Czech May PMI collapsed to a 33-month low driven by the new orders and the new export orders. Exports growth was stable in the first quarter of 2012 but would have likely slowed in the second quarter adding to downside pressure on growth. The outlook for the manufacturing sector has deteriorated sharply in the last couple of months following Nov-11 to Mar-12 recovery”.
Manufacturing activity in Turkey also fell back to near the 50 no change level, which is again worrying, because one of the growth areas we should be looking for is in emerging markets.
Commenting on the Turkey survey, Dr. Murat Ulgen, Chief Economist, Central & Eastern Europe and sub-Saharan Africa at HSBC, said:
“Manufacturing sector growth almost stalled in May, after a notable improvement in April due to a very subdued rise in output volumes and a minor contraction in new orders. New export orders, on the other hand, showed a slight improvement, suggesting that the slowdown in economic activity is driven more by moderating domestic demand, while Turkish exporters continue to successfully diversify geographies for trade”.
Even Asia is not the momentum powerhouse it was six months ago. In what has now become a familiar pattern, Chinese activity weakened yet again. The rate of incoming new business has now contracted for seven consecutive months.The HSBC Purchasing Managers’ Index registered 48.4 in May, down slightly from 49.3 in April, signalling a seventh successive month-on-month worsening of Chinese manufacturing sector operating conditions. Neither export demand, nor internal consumption, nor even strong loan stimulus seem able to sustain the staggering giant at the moment.
Japanese industry continues to move sideways, with an ongoing decline in export activity being offset by domestic demand which is fueled by the continuous stimulus and reconstruction spending by the government. The order book is a good indicator in this sense.
As the report says:
“The latest rise in new orders was the fifth in as many months. Companies mainly attributed new order growth to better demand from domestic sources. Although only slight, the overall increase in new orders contrasted with a further decline in new work received from overseas clients. Goods producers commented on muted demand from China and Europe”.
Activity in India simply held steady.
Leif Eskesen, Chief Economist for India & ASEAN at HSBC said:
“Activity in the Indian manufacturing sector kept up the pace in May with output, quantity of purchases and employment expanding at a faster pace. New orders decelerated slightly led by domestic orders and stock levels rose, suggesting a slight moderation in output growth going ahead”.
At 54.0, down from 56.0 in April, the final Markit U.S. Manufacturing Purchasing Managers’ Index came in a tad higher than the earlier flash estimate of 53.9 but nevertheless still signaled the weakest improvement in business conditions since February.New orders, in contrast, showed a slightly smaller rise than indicated by the flash estimate, taking growth sharply lower than seen in both April and March. The weaker growth of total new orders reflected to a large extent a near-stagnation of new export orders for the second successive month, which contrasted with more robust growth rates seen earlier in the year. The marginal rise in new export orders was also even smaller than the flash estimate.
Commenting on the final PMI data, Chris Williamson, Chief Economist at Markit said:
“The final PMI data confirm the earlier flash reading showing growth in the U.S. manufacturing sector to have slowed in May. The sector nevertheless continued to expand at a reasonable pace, growing at an annualised rate of around 3%, and should contribute to sustaining steady though unspectacular economic growth in the second quarter”.
Further South, May data signaled a second monthly decline in both output and new orders at Brazilian manufacturers. Nevertheless, at 49.3, unchanged from April, the PMI was only slightly below the neutral threshold suggesting only a modest deterioration in Brazilian manufacturing business conditions. Firms working in Brazil’s manufacturing sector generally linked the deterioration in operating conditions to weak client demand. The volume of new orders received by companies fell for the second consecutive month in May, albeit the decline was only modest and to a lesser extent than in April. Meanwhile, new export orders also fell during May, with the rate of decline solid and the strongest in 2012 to date.
Commenting on the Brazil survey, Andre Loes, Chief Economist, Brazil at HSBC said:
“The HSBC Manufacturing PMI index remained unchanged at 49.3 in May. This is the second consecutive month where the manufacturing PMI has been below 50 (after above-50 readings in the first quarter), and reinforces the perception that Brazil’s manufacturing sector is going through a particularly difficult time, squeezed between rising costs on one side, and competition from imports on the other.
One Easy Reading
There is one simple, easy and unequivocal message to be garnered from all this – the Euro crisis needs to be settled and resolved in the shortest time possible. This won’t be easy, but it has to be done. What was once a small localized crisis with its epicenter in Greece, having spread to the entire Euro Area is now extending beyond the frontier of the monetary union, and threatening the entire recovery on a global basis, as investors loose their appetite for risk fearing the arrival of another Lehman moment. Naturally, the problem isn’t only the Euro, most developed economies are over leveraged and struggling under the weight of legacy debt.
Meanwhile China offers another warning. Simply pumping up demand in unsustainable quantities in areas like construction may bring short term export advantage for the West, but in the longer term the problems produced make the process hardly worth the effort, a point which could well be borne in mind when thinking about policy towards the Indias, Turkeys and Brazils of this world, where short term capital flows have pumped up consumer credit in undesirable ways. Since these countries have started increasing credit from a very low base, the threat is hardly dire at this point, but warnings should be heeded. With domestic mortgages at something like 5% of GDP Brazil is somewhere near where Spain was in 1992. No big deal, but imagine the process is allowed to continue unchecked, and then look where Spain is now, or rather was when the bubble burst in 2007, a mere 15 years later.
This post first appeared on my Roubini Global Economonitor Blog “Don’t Shoot The Messenger“.
Other analysis posts on Jobs
Other analysis posts on Manufacturing
Other analysis posts on Exports