FREE NEWSLETTER: Econintersect sends a nightly newsletter highlighting news events of the day, and providing a summary of new articles posted on the website. Econintersect will not sell or pass your email address to others per our privacy policy. You can cancel this subscription at any time by selecting the unsubscribing link in the footer of each email.

posted on 08 October 2016

The Truth About Meritocracy: It Doesn't Make Society Fairer

from The Conversation

-- this post authored by Ye Liu, King's College London

At the core of Theresa May’s reasons for lifting the ban on new grammar schools in September was, the prime minister argued, her desire for “Britain to be the world’s great meritocracy". Reiterating this again at the Conservative Party conference a month later, she said that she wants to “build a country that truly works for everyone, not just the privileged few".

By mining a recurrent theme of British politicians with her focus on meritocracy, May argues that by rewarding those who excel and work hard, her government will build a fair society in a country left fractured after the Brexit vote. But she should beware: educational meritocracy is a facade that holds little promise of creating an equitable or egalitarian society.

Meritocratic dystopia

It was Michael Young - father of the journalist and free school founder Toby Young - who first coined the term "meritocracy" in his 1958 book The Rise of the Meritocracy. It was also Young, ironically, who provided its first full-blown critique. His book is now best known as a satire on a future society where merit is defined as “IQ plus effort" and social stratification determined by IQ testing. Young’s book is clearly no manifesto for meritocracy and it holds out little prospect that meritocratic forms of selection will necessarily be equitable, let alone egalitarian. But there is also a more positive message in the book about improving equality of opportunity as a means to make meritocracy more acceptable.

In practice, Young’s ideas on equality of opportunity were primarily focused on educational opportunities. As an egalitarian, he deplored Britain’s divisive system of secondary schools to which children were selected through the 11+ exam, based on narrow measurements of IQ. He therefore supported the development of non-selective comprehensive secondary schools to replace the tripartite system of grammar, technical and secondary modern schools. He also supported wider social access to higher education through his promotion of an Open University which was finally inaugurated by Harold Wilson’s Labour government in 1964.

So Young broadly supported rewards based on merit, but only when underpinned by greater equality in opportunities. What he did not support was a narrow form of meritocracy where merit was judged according to the results of unreliable forms of IQ testing leading to highly unequal forms of education. He was disappointed to find the term meritocracy, which he had coined, being widely taken up as an ideal by the Tony Blair government without awareness of the problems which had been shown to attend it.

May: a bright future for the chosen. Facundo Arrizabalaga/EPA

Politically attractive

The political attractions of meritocracy are evident and it has been widely accepted as an important element in the ideology of various centre-left parties in Europe. Meritocracy was identified by the European Union as a key characteristic of educational and social policy to look out for within former Soviet-block countries aiming to enter the European project.

In China, the Gaokao, a highly selective entrance examination for the higher education system, was re-introduced in 1977 after the country’s chaotic ten-year Cultural Revolution. As my new research has shown, by promoting the Gaokao as a mechanism for meritocratic selection, the Chinese Communist Party was seen as taking a groundbreaking step away from social selection based on political affiliation. But while the Gaokao selection test purported to represent meritocratic selection, in fact it legitimised the privileges of those new elites who seized new political and economic power as China went through a period of market reform.

The Gaokao has meant that lower social groups, such as the working class and peasants who lost their previous social security and welfare, believe that if young people fail the exams or only achieve access to non-prestigious institutions, they are of inferior intelligence. It has stopped them challenging the unfairness of a system that means the children of urban professionals and political elites are more likely to have access to better higher education opportunities. At the same time, it has minimised the importance of the state spending money on policies that would reduce social inequality among different regions and between the rural and the urban.

A fairer society?

May is now using the promise of a new educational meritocracy as part of her appeal to the “just managing" - at a time when persistent social inequality and Brexit have led to division. But it’s not clear if and how a new set of grammar schools will provide more opportunities for upward social mobility for working-class children.

Yet, we can draw from Young’s predictions about what a mature meritocracy would look like. Social status would be determined exclusively by a narrowly defined system of merit, and social inequality for those left behind is a necessary byproduct of rewarding those who excel. This allows no alibis for failure and is likely to be a harsher and more unforgiving type of class society than what preceded it.

The ConversationYe Liu, Lecturer in International Development, King's College London

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

>>>>> Scroll down to view and make comments <<<<<<

Click here for Historical Opinion Post Listing

Make a Comment

Econintersect wants your comments, data and opinion on the articles posted. You can also comment using Facebook directly using he comment block below.

Econintersect Opinion


Print this page or create a PDF file of this page
Print Friendly and PDF

The growing use of ad blocking software is creating a shortfall in covering our fixed expenses. Please consider a donation to Econintersect to allow continuing output of quality and balanced financial and economic news and analysis.

Take a look at what is going on inside of
Main Home
Analysis Blog
Slow Economic Growth Will Be Around For A Long Time
The Job Guarantee, Wage-Price Inflation And Alternative Solutions: Part 2
News Blog
March 2017 Conference Board Consumer Confidence Highest Since 2000
Richmond Fed Manufacturing Survey Again Improves In March 2017.
Case-Shiller 20 City Home Price Index January 2017 Shows 5.7 % Year-over-Year Growth
A Changing Rulebook To Tame The New Global Arms Race
Infographic Of The Day: Chart: Understanding Alphabet's 4 Billion Dollar In "Other Bets"
Early Headlines: Asia Stocks And Dollar Up, Oil, Gold Steady, Obama Climate Policies Gone, US Oil Glut, Euro Surges, Shorts Remain, Trump Into Yemen?, Iran-Russia Deals, Cat 4 Cyclone Hits Oz, And More
March 27, 2017 Weather and Climate Report - Will the MJO Deliver a Nino?
The Most Reputable Companies Worldwide
Gut Bacteria Play A Role In Long-term Weight Gain
What We Read Today 27 March 2017 - Special Public Edition
Is Less More In The Smartphone Market
Average Gasoline Prices for Week Ending 27 March 2017 Statistically Unchanged - Again
What We Read Today 27 March 2017
Investing Blog
The Dollar's Coming Impact On Markets
The Real 401k Plan Manager 27 March 2017
Opinion Blog
Macron May Lead But Le Pen Remains The Big Story
Is The 20th Century Still The 'Hayek Century'?
Precious Metals Blog
These Gold Stocks Will Produce Much Bigger Gains Than Gold Itself
Live Markets
28Mar2017 Pre-Market Commentary: Wall Street Eyes A Lower Opening, Crude Prices Edge Higher, Investors Await Fed Members Clues On Timing Of Next Rate Hike
Amazon Books & More

.... and keep up with economic news using our dynamic economic newspapers with the largest international coverage on the internet
Asia / Pacific
Middle East / Africa
USA Government



Analysis Blog
News Blog
Investing Blog
Opinion Blog
Precious Metals Blog
Markets Blog
Video of the Day


Asia / Pacific
Middle East / Africa
USA Government

RSS Feeds / Social Media

Combined Econintersect Feed

Free Newsletter

Marketplace - Books & More

Economic Forecast

Content Contribution



  Top Economics Site Contributor TalkMarkets Contributor Finance Blogs Free PageRank Checker Active Search Results Google+

This Web Page by Steven Hansen ---- Copyright 2010 - 2017 Econintersect LLC - all rights reserved