De-evolution of Western Economies

August 30th, 2011
in Op Ed

by Guest Author Eduard Fischer

(Click on cartoon for larger image.)

de-evolution-of-man So here we are at the cusp of another bear market, or some might call it the next leg down in a cyclical bear market. Or is it just a bull market correction? Why are stocks selling off and what is likely to happen next?

To answer that question we need to look at the state of two of the dominant world economies, the US and Europe.

Devolution in a political sense usually refers to the transfer of powers from a dominant entity to a lesser one, for instance the transfer of power from a federal government to the state level. I want to propose use of a new term, de-evolution, which has a somewhat similar inference, but in an economic sense – this would be when a dominant economic power, willingly or unwillingly, hands off economic power to other entities.  I believe that this has happened to both the US and Northern Europe but in somewhat different ways.  Let’s start with the US.

Follow up:

Problems in the US

Median wages in the US have not increased in real terms for over a decade. This applies not only to factory and trades jobs but also to many highly skilled jobs in the IT industry where many salaries are now actually dropping. After all, in a highly competitive global economy why would IBM hire a programmer in the US when it can now get a highly skilled recruit who will work for much lower wages in India?

Is this fair? That question should be irrelevant in an article if the purpose should be to get an edge on the market as opposed to presenting moral or ideological points of view.  However I want to make an observation somewhat related because I believe that it bears great relevance on how the transfer of economic power has taken place.  The technological revolution that has taken place in the last few decades, especially in IT, has largely been the result of the ingenuity of Americans.  Those Americans were educated in an education system largely funded by American taxpayers.  In addition, much of the basic R and D that led to many technological breakthroughs was largely publicly funded. Now that technical know-how has been taken overseas, legally through outsourcing by American-based corporations, as well as illegally through the theft of intellectual property.

Whether this was fair to the US taxpayer or not, we can’t put the genie back in the bottle at this point. This transfer of intellectual wealth has lifted millions of people out of poverty in other countries. As a non-American I can say: Thank you America.

Wage Arbitrage

The problem for the US is that this process is creating global wage arbitrage. Even as American-based corporations have increased profits, Americans, on average, are growing poorer. The very wealthy are, by and large, an exception to this, which seems to be one way the US is regressing into a third world style economic stratification. The reversal of wage growth is a very serious problem for the US because of consumer indebtedness and particularly government indebtedness at every level. Debt per se is not a problem as long as an individual’s income or a nation’s wealth is growing sufficiently. But neither is the case in the US. The credit rating of the US government was recently downgraded by S&P not because of the level of debt, but primarily because every projection of GDP growth presented by the various factions and committees in congress was completely unrealistic. In addition, none of them took into account even the possibility of another recession in the next decade, which is fantasy and denial, bordering on insanity.

"Printing" Money for the World

There are those that believe that the US Federal Reserve can just keep on printing money and so the debt will not be a problem. There are even those who say the term “printing money” is totally misleading. Yet I have heard the chairman of the Fed call it that on a number of occasions, so I guess that he must be as misinformed as I am. Which brings me to another point: many commentators on this site say that those who believe that the federal government debt is a serious problem do not understand the reserve banking system. It’s true that I don’t entirely understand it. But I don’t have to in order to understand this: either Mr. Bernanke, unlike me, understands the reserve banking system, or he doesn’t. It can’t be both. I have heard Mr. Bernanke in testimony in front of congress several times state that the national debt is a huge problem that will cause a crisis if left on its current course. So if the chairman of the Fed, Helicopter Ben, says there is a problem with the debt, perhaps we should listen. And if the chairman of the Fed doesn’t know what he is talking about, then this is a big problem for the economy in any case.

I do understand that in principle there is nothing wrong with the central bank creating new money as long as the industrial capacity of the country is under-utilized and the new money can be quickly mopped up by the renewed output. This would be true in a closed economy, which the US is not. Much of this newly printed money is going overseas.

I personally would prefer to buy a US made product over a Chinese made one, and pay considerably more, because of the generally much higher quality. But where can I even buy a “made in the USA” light bulb or kitchen appliance these days? Manufacturing in the US is now down to about 13% of GDP, considerably lower than even Canada’s, which is considered a resource-based economy. This is why printing money has been good for the multi-national’s profits but has not helped the US economy.

GDP Mirage

There are those who point to US GDP and say that the US economy is still three times the size of China’s. Well that depends on how you measure. In terms of real outputs China has already surpassed the US.  Much of what is measured in US GDP does not create real wealth: fighting wars does not create wealth, lawyering in the most litigious society in history does not create wealth, an expensive and inefficient medical system does not create wealth, locking up and maintaining 1% of the adult population in prisons does not create wealth, and retailing made in China goods to each other does not create wealth.  But all this is added as a plus to GDP.  My point is that, although US corporations are efficient, the economy as a whole is not.

Consumption over Production

The gross error in US economic thinking has been that consumption, or even gluttony, is always good and perhaps even the highest good.  As if America only has to supply ravenous consumers and a printing press and all will be well.  American consumers have proven that they will drag themselves to the shopping mall even with a huge burden of debt and two broken legs, but that time may be ending.

The average American has been beguiled over the last 15 years or so into believing that he or she is getting wealthier mainly through the extension of credit.  The great surge in the real estate market and the apparent increase in wealth that it caused was due to a massive overextension of credit by the banks.  After the real estate crash the government has taken over the extension of credit to consumers through tax breaks and the attempt to maintain positive GDP through unsustainable deficit spending.  The conundrum for the government now is that any move to reduce the deficit will immediately lead to recession, which in turn, with this level of consumer and government debt and unemployment, will quickly lead to a depression.

Europe’s Problems

Europe’s problems are related but somewhat different. True, the rising Asian economies have offered competition, but the stronger northern European manufacturing economies, particularly Germany’s, have weathered this quite well. Germany’s big mistake was joining the EU.  This precipitated a different kind of de-evolution where weaker economies were empowered by joining the common currency and their real wages there went up drastically while productivity was not proportionally improved, or in the case of Greece, actually declined. This monetary union was encouraged by short-term greed on the part of the German corporations and banks that acquired new customers whose wages had suddenly jumped while tariffs were dropped.

Can Germany Carry the Unproductive?

Now the long-term consequences are coming home and the corporations and banks expect the German government and taxpayers to hold this mess together.  Good luck with that. Over the last 30 years the Germans have done an amazing job in assimilating an impoverished former East Germany and reviving it.  It took hard work and sacrifice.  I remember during the fall of the Berlin wall in 1989 one commentator saying, “Now the Germans will have to swallow a porcupine.” Well they did it, but they are not about to try and swallow a rhinoceros, or a bunch of PIGS, for that matter.  If Angela Merkel does not pull the plug, then the Germans will elect a party in 2013 that will take them out of the EU.  The less productive countries in Europe will have to devalue their currencies; I see no other choice. Right now the countries in Europe are like a group of swimmers chained together, none of whom is free to use life saving strokes.

I do not include Ireland in the group of less productive countries by the way, because it is not. The Irish merely got royally screwed by their banks and their government.

Of course the break up of the EU will cause enormous upheaval. It can’t be avoided now. This sets up the perfect storm as the wheels are coming off the US and European economies at the same time. Even though I have been bearish for some time I am not gloating here. I am just describing the dark line on the horizon that I now see after watching a very red sunrise and the barometer plummet. Every sailor will know what I mean by that analogy.

The Out-look for Multinational Profits

Some will argue that even with the decline of the economies in the West, the profits of multi national corporations will continue to hold or even improve because of the growth of economies in Asia.  I personally think that this is very unlikely, at least for a considerable time.  The US has been the hub of the world economy for quite a while, and the EU’s GDP is actually even larger.  Things are happening much too fast now for economic order to prevail.  Cracks are appearing weekly and are spider webbing through the American and European economies.  Even a moderate slowdown in consumption in the US and Europe would have an impact on the Chinese economy; a major downturn in the West will wreck havoc and likely cause social unrest.

Financial Analysts:  US Market Will Go Up

A CNN poll among professional financial analysts on Monday came out with the average consensus that the S&P index (SPY) will finish the year at 1350. I will refrain from making fun of this because timing the market is hard and I don’t always get it right. And who knows? There may be another unfathomable wave of optimism and the cans on both continents may get kicked down the road once again. But that is beginning to look more and more unlikely day by day.

General Public:  Depression

While economists and money managers largely profess confidence, a survey by CNN even two months ago of the general populace in the US found that almost 50% believed that the country would be in a depression within a year. The loss of confidence in the markets in the last few weeks is telling. A series of 4% plus daily drops like we have seen lately is extremely unusual. Combined with the flight to short-term treasuries and gold, it seems that dark clouds are gathering.

Intelligent and cogent rebuttals are welcomed and encouraged.

Related Articles

Michigan Consumer Sentiment 4th Worse on Record by Doug Short

Mistaken Monetary Policy Lessons from Japan? by John Muellbauer and Keiko Murata

Global Economic Downturn:  A Crisis of Political Economy by George Friedman

Prediction:  Demand Will Rule the World by Michael Pettis

Does Germany have to have Net exports to Bail-out the Periphery? by Dirk Ehnts

Sophie's Choice for the EU by Dirk Ehnts

Eurozone Crises left to Fester by Daniel Gros

The Eurozone in Bad Need of a Psychiatrist by Stefano Micossi

Eurozone - Caught in a Financial - Sovereign Web by Clive Corcoran

Analysis Blog articles by Elliott Morss

About the Author

Eduard-Fischer Eduard Fischer is a British Columbia mountain resident with a lasting interest in economics, finance, investing and political economy.  He co-founded, managed, and sold a couple of reasonably successful businesses including The Edge Climbing Centre, one of North America’s first major indoor climbing gyms. He has  also co-owned and managed a manufacturing and export business.  He is currently starting yet another business.  Eduard and his wife are avid mountain adventurers.  Some of their experiences over 26 years can be reviewed at

Make a Comment

Econintersect wants your comments, data and opinion on the articles posted.  As the internet is a "war zone" of trolls, hackers and spammers - Econintersect must balance its defences against ease of commenting.  We have joined with Livefyre to manage our comment streams.

To comment, just click the "Sign In" button at the top-left corner of the comment box below. You can create a commenting account using your favorite social network such as Twitter, Facebook, Google+, LinkedIn or Open ID - or open a Livefyre account using your email address.


  1. Frank Li says :

    Good job, Ed!

  2. Ames Tiedeman says :

    Lower taxes? Higher taxes? Does anyone actually think being plus or minus 5% on taxes will make a lick of difference for the U.S. economy at this stage in the game? The economy will never again work the way we all want it to work with the current account deficit at 6 or 7 percent of GDP. You cannot get unemployment even under 6% without a credit bubble, with a current account deficit as large as ours. We have not had a trade surplus since 1974. We have been in decline for 40 years and this decline has only accelerated in recent years. We closed 55,000 plants in the United States since 1980. Your politicians won't tell you this because some of them fed you the false promise of free trade. Others don't want to admit NAFTA has been a complete failure for America. Great for Mexico as that giant "sucking sound" Ross Perot predicted has materialized. Clinton and Gore promised the American people ever bigger trade surpluses with Mexico and ten's of thousands of new high paying jobs. Just pass NAFTA they exclaimed! Quite laughable, really. We have gone from a trade surplus of a few billion a year to a trade deficit nearing 100 billion per annum with Mexico. What is equally as laughable or insulting is the trade deal Obama has just signed with Columbia. Do we make anything they can afford? Of course not. Columbia will simply become a new launch pad to make textiles and sell them into America. How about the trade deal Obama signed with South Korea? This is an interesting one. Within the bill on the U.S. side is a provision to provide worker training for displaced Americans. So we are now so stupid that we are signing trade deals that we know will diminish the U.S. labor force. The insanity is just that! Does anyone think the South Koreans would agree to a trade deal if they were not sure to win? Does Obama understand that the South Koreans are fierce nationalists who will never let America win a trade contest? Did my ancestors lead pre-Revolutionary War skirmishes against the British at Lexington and Concord in 1775 and early 1776 only to have America end up how it is today? My blood has been on this land since 1635. How many of my ancestors ever dreamed that America would be so deep in debt and short in ideas? Would any of them ever have thought that such mediocre men would one day be leading this nation? America has done a terrific job of creating a low employment and low wage society, for millions. Quite sad indeed. No civilization has succeeded by consuming more than it produces. We must massively restructure. Until America decides to produce what it consumes you can forget about any long term economic recovery. The financial games all failed. The credit bubble is gone and now the U.S. economy is exposed as the biggest joke of all time. Credit bubbles have a way of masking the real issues. How do we fix the American economy? Start by making every American who has received a Nobel Prize in economics return the award. Why? because they were either 100% wrong or their work proved to be of no benefit to the American economy. Next, round up every economist who advised Nixon that if America left the gold standard and moved the world to a floating currency regime; that America would never, ever, run a current account deficit. And I am very sorry to inform everyone that this would include the late and great Milton Friedman. Sorry Milton, you were dead wrong too! Next, leave the WTO, end NAFTA, and go about setting up country-by-country trade deals that are realistic based on where America stands today. It is not 1955 anymore. The world has either matched us or surpassed us in industry after industry. We have literally become an emerging economy is some industries as we have faltered so badly. Next, move to a flat tax, and end all farm subsidies. Cancel most government social programs like food stamps and deport 100% of the people living in America illegally. Make it a high crime to employ anyone not here legally. Finally, for major industries such as steel and automobiles, move to a must-be-made-in-America policy. No longer allow imports of products in specific industries. They must all be made in America. We must employ our people. We can no longer employ the world via our consumption as so many Americans remain unemployed. We must use our 50 state union to our advantage. We must promote massive trade between the states. We must socialize CAPITALISM to avoid becoming a socialist state! We must reinvigorate the American people. We must manufacture. And who running for office can lead America on this grand and pious endeavor? Who running for office today has the passion of a General MacArthur or the skill of a Chester Nimitz? Who has the energy of a Teddy Roosevelt? The men who command the attention of the electorate in this age of mediocre ambition are all too small to make a difference...



Analysis Blog
News Blog
Investing Blog
Opinion Blog
Precious Metals Blog
Markets Blog
Video of the Day


Asia / Pacific
Middle East / Africa
USA Government

RSS Feeds / Social Media

Combined Econintersect Feed

Free Newsletter

Marketplace - Books & More

Economic Forecast

Content Contribution



  Top Economics Site Contributor TalkMarkets Contributor Finance Blogs Free PageRank Checker Active Search Results Google+

This Web Page by Steven Hansen ---- Copyright 2010 - 2016 Econintersect LLC - all rights reserved